Now all roads lead to France and heavy is the tread
Of the living; but the dead returning lightly dance.
Edward Thomas, Roads

Thursday, April 16, 2015

Recommended: A Visual Approach to World War I History


Regular readers of Roads to the Great War know that we have a dedicated band of regular contributors. One of these is my friend Cyril Mazansky, who is a man of many parts, and one of his special areas of interest is World War I cigarette cards.  We recently received a review copy of Cyril's new book on that subject,  The First World War on Cigarette and Trade Cards: An Illustrated and Descriptive History. It's absolutely a delight — not just a book on a collectible — but in the aggregate a history of the war in visual form. Every aspect of the war is covered: uniforms, aircraft, weaponry, cartoons, photos from the battlefield, notable figures, and much more. Each card has a photo or well-done illustration on one side and a brief, but informative, description on the back.  Our literary editor, David Beer, is preparing a review, but we wanted to let you know that Cyril Mazansky's enjoyable work is available now. Here are some of the hundreds of examples from the work as a printable poster for you.  



Order Now

Wednesday, April 15, 2015

Centennial at the Grass Roots: Sacramento, California, Observes the Centennial


For the second year, the city of Sacramento is holding a series of  presentations on the events of 100 years past. Here is their 1915–2015 commemorative program. You might notice that your editor is the featured speaker on 31 May.  Hope to see you there.
MH


F

Tuesday, April 14, 2015

Artillery Scout: The Story of a Forward Observer with the U.S. Field Artillery in World War I
Reviewed by Peter Belmonte


Artillery Scout: The Story of a Forward Observer with the U.S. Field Artillery in World War I
by James G. Bilder
Casement, 2014


Leonard Fairfield, the subject of this book, was author James Bilder's grandfather. Bilder knew his grandfather had reservations about U.S. involvement in the war; he suspected that many other Doughboys shared those reservations. Many of these Doughboys, like the country as a whole, reluctantly entered the war. Bilder wrote this book to tell his grandfather's story. In the process he shows how these Doughboys persevered and helped to defeat Germany.


American Artillery Firing Near Exermont, Argonne Sector

Fairfield was born in Chicago in 1892, the son of an English Protestant father and Irish Catholic mother. Len's father had a drinking problem and wasn't an adequate provider, and the family struggled with poverty. Despite disadvantages, Len studied and was able to become a stationary engineer. As war neared, Len had serious doubts as to the validity of U.S. involvement. Doubts aside, Len was drafted as part of the first quota in September 1917. Told there were too many inductees at the armory, Len was ordered to return home and report again on 3 October. He did so, and was sent to Camp Grant, near Rockford, Illinois, for his training.

Len was assigned to Battery A, 124th Field Artillery Regiment, 58th Field Artillery Brigade, 33rd Division. Going overseas in May 1918, the 124th underwent more training at Camp Valdahon before going into action. Typical of some artillery units, the 58th Field Artillery Brigade didn't serve with its parent division (the 33rd) during the war. Instead it supported a number of different divisions in combat. At St. Mihiel, the 58th supported the 1st Division in its assault against the ground overlooked by the dreaded Mont Sec. During the Meuse-Argonne Offensive the 58th supported, in turn, the 91st, 32nd, and 89th Divisions. During the last phase of the offensive, Len lived through a horrific shelling of his column as it moved forward in close support of the infantry. The days of constant combat, exposure to gas, and the terrible climate slowly took its toll on Len; the war ended none too soon for him as he teetered on the brink of serious illness.

After a brief period of occupation duty in Luxembourg, during which time Len spent a month in the hospital suffering from influenza and pneumonia, Len finally returned home to his wife Maggie, whom he had married in Chicago just before departing for military service. Bilder includes a brief epilogue that covers Len's post-war life, much of which was filled with raising his large family.


Order Now
Statements made in the Foreword, Introduction, and Acknowledgements sections of the book indicate that Bilder used letters and secondhand recollections of his grandfather, as well as other family archives, for the foundation of the story. For background information, he consulted several military historians and artillery experts and used diaries of some unit officers. Unfortunately, the book is not footnoted and there is no bibliography, so it is impossible to determine the origin of the information presented in the book.

Readers familiar with Robert Casey's The Cannoneers Have Hairy Ears: A Diary of the Front Lines (New York: J. H. Sears) will recognize many of the episodes in Bilder's book. Casey was the executive officer of Battery A, and Bilder must have used his published diary as a reference.

At the Business End of a French 75
Using the perspective of what students of literature call an "omniscient observer", Bilder recreates thoughts, conversations, and actions based upon information gleaned from the above-mentioned sources, particularly Casey's diary. While some quotations might be from an officer's diary, for example, others might be based upon Bilder's assumption of what probably was said or done given the situation at hand. The resultant story reads like a novel. With foregoing in mind, I would not categorize this as a scholarly study. However, in telling Len's story, Bilder covers training methods, artillery tactics, and tools and equipment used by artillerymen plying their deadly trade. We learn about their duties, to include working with recalcitrant horses and moving mountains of ammunition crates from depots to the gun pits. Len, a dutiful if reluctant soldier, was smart and cynical, with an acerbic sense of humor.

If you don't mind a book with recreated dialog and occasional salty "soldiers' language" in the dialog and the narrative, then you will appreciate this book as an addition to the overall history of the experiences of the American soldier in the Great War.

Peter Belmonte

Monday, April 13, 2015

An American-Built Fighter for the AEF: The Packard-Lepere Lusac 11


Designed in 1917 by Capt. Georges LePere, a French aeronautical engineer working for the U.S. Army Air Service, the LUSAC 11 was the result of efforts to get an American-built fighter into combat as soon as possible. The acronym "LUSAC" stood for LePere United States Army Combat. LePere designed the LUSAC 11 to be a combination fighter, light bomber, and reconnaissance aircraft that carried a pilot and an observer/gunner. 

Capt. LePere, along with several other French aviation engineers, worked on the design at the Packard Motor Car Co. of Detroit, Mich. Packard provided design and fabrication space and additional engineers, and the first prototype was completed in April 1918. After the three prototypes received generally favorable reviews from test pilots at Wilbur Wright Field, Ohio, the Bureau of Aircraft Production planned to order as many as 3,525 LUSAC 11s. 


At war's end in November 1918, however, the Bureau cancelled its contracts, and only 28 production aircraft were built (with only seven of these built before the Armistice, none saw combat). The aircraft continued to fly in the Air Service, and a specially modified LUSAC 11 became famous by setting a number of altitude records at Wright Field in the early 1920s.

The aircraft on display, the only LUSAC 11 in existence, originally went to France just before the end of the war. In 1989 the museum acquired it from the Musée de l'Air in Paris, France. After extensive restoration by museum personnel, it went on display in 1992. It is marked as it appeared while at the Allied test facility in Orly, France, in late 1918.

TECHNICAL NOTES:
Armament: Two .30-cal. Marlin and two .30-cal. Lewis machine guns
Engine: Liberty 12 of 400 hp
Maximum speed: 136 mph
Cruising speed: 118 mph
Range: 320 miles
Ceiling: 20,200 ft. (modified LUSAC 11 up to 39,700 ft. with turbo supercharger)
Span: 41 ft. 7 in.
Length: 25 ft. 3 in.
Height: 10 ft. 7 in.
Weight: 3,746 lbs. loaded
Serial number: SC 42133

Source:  The USAF National Museum

Sunday, April 12, 2015

How Was the Trench Stalemate Finally Broken?

In early 1918 German forces found a way to penetrate deep into the Allied lines.  The German infiltration tactics of 1918 can be summarized under four headings: innovative artillery preparation; the combined arms assault or storm battalion; rejection of the linear advance in favor of bypassing enemy centers of resistance; and attacks to disorganize the enemy rear area.

Col. Georg Bruckmüller

The key was artillery. Col. Georg Bruckmüller, an obscure officer retired for nervous problems in 1913 but recalled to duty for the war, developed German artillery techniques to a fine art by the time of the Ludendorff Spring Offensives of 1918. The essence of the Bruckmüller artillery preparation was a carefully orchestrated, short but intense bombardment designed to isolate, demoralize, and disorganize enemy defenders. Georg Bruckmüller avoided area targets, concentrating on such key points as artillery observation posts, command posts, radio and telephone centers, rearward troop concentrations, bridges, and major approach routes. He carefully pinpointed all these targets on aerial photographs. The result was to knock out enemy communications and isolate forward units.

Stormtroopers Inside Enemy Wire Following a Barrage

The effect was increased by surprise. At the start of the German offensive on 21 March 1918, Bruckmüller began his bombardment with ten minutes of gas shells to force the British to mask, followed by four hours and 25 minutes of mixed gas and high explosives. The preparatory fires shifted back and forth, so that the British did not know when the artillery was actually lifting for the infantry advance. Meanwhile, automatic rifle teams moved as close as possible to the British positions during the bombardment. When the Germans did advance, they moved behind a rolling barrage, further enhanced by intense fog. The combination of surprise, brevity, intensity, and carefully selected targets was unique.

Captain Jonathan M. House, U.S. Army, 1984

Saturday, April 11, 2015

Colored Lantern Slides from the Salvation Army

The Salvation Army became an innovator during the 19th century at using hand-colored slides to document and promote their service. The early projectors or lanterns they used were illuminated by gas-heated lime-blocks. Naturally, they used the technology to record their work in France during the Great War.

Susan Mitchem of the Salvation Army National Archives has provided these image for us.

Only One Bag Allowed

A Larger Service Hut

The Troops at Leisure

Supply Truck with Salvation Army Sign

Doughboys on Their Way to the Front

Burial Service

A Salvation Army Ensign Baking Pies

The Most Popular Contribution to the Doughboy's Well Being

Lining Up for Doughnuts


Friday, April 10, 2015

Remembering a Veteran: Lt. Elmer Focke, Survivor of the Rock of the Marne Episode Gets Wounded


First Lt. Elmer J. Focke of the 38th Infantry, 3rd Division, survived the brutal  fighting of the Rock of the Marne incident of 15 July 1918, when his unit was instrumental in turning back the last German offensive of the war. He was later wounded in the arm during the subsequent fighting in the Second Battle of the Marne as his division advanced north after crossing the Marne and had fought its way to the south bank of the Vesle River. His account: 


On the day I was wounded August 8, 1918, I was in a gravel pit with my platoon. It was early morning and we had orders to move out, and move we did. It was on a slight hillside and as we went down this gravel road, there stood Father Gainey, our Chaplain, with a gold cross, blessing each group as it passed by him. This was the only time in my life I ever felt the blessing was meant for me. 

We were deployed in an open field with no cover, moving towards our objective, when Dewey Reeves who was four or five feet in front of me with his gun in his outstretched arms, turned and fell dead. I never once have felt anything but love for my country, but as you get older, war seems so damn foolish. I don't remember being told this, but it seems like an unwritten law. It's normal, thinking that a man would stop to help a wounded soldier, but the end result would be if there were many wounded, the Captain would end up with out a company. We were told somewhere alone the line that the Brigadier General who had ordered us down this open terrain in broad daylight, with no cover, was relieved of his command. 

It might be of interest to know how soldiers who are wounded are evacuated from the front lines. I was fortunate in being wounded in my left arm, so I was a walking case and needed no help. I put my watchband above my wound and twisted it with a stick I found to stop the bleeding. I remained at the front all morning. Walking to the rear was a very sad experience for me. Some of the soldiers who were seriously wounded the day before and were not yet evacuated, were lying in open fields moaning and crying. I noticed a First Aid Station and it was here that I was given an anti-tetanus shot. I then walked back to Chateau Thierry where the wounded were tagged and assigned to various hospitals. I don't know where it was, but I finally landed in a Convent. 


A Salvation Army Worker Assisting an American "Walking Wounded"

The operating room was a big room with four operating tables being used at the same time. One thing I remember I was embarrassed about my personal appearance and hygiene and said to the doctor "Would you believe that back in the states I use to wear silk underwear". They did not remove the large slug from my arm, but rather had me sent to a larger hospital in Paris. This hospital was formerly an American girl's  art school and was run by the American Red Cross. While hospitalized in Paris I had an experience which was very enjoyable. My nurse was an American. Being a walking patient, we finally got around to having a date. I had no money and she paid for everything we did and saw. 

After getting well I was ordered back to the front. Headquarters were in Nancy, France. A farmer once walked up to me and thanked me for all that the Americans were doing for his country. He then offered his daughter for me to sleep with. I declined the offer, and that may seem strange to those not there in France, but that was how things were done over there during a time of war. I was soon sent back to the front lines.


Thursday, April 9, 2015

Inside Observer: Grand Duke Alexander Mikhailovich of Russia

By Assistant Editor Kimball Worcester



The Grand Duke Alexander Mikhailovich (“Sandro”, 1866–1933) was opportunely positioned to have an opinion in depth about the Tsar and the immediate prewar situation in Russia. Not only was he an admiral of the Imperial Russian Fleet who served during the Russo-Japanese War, he was also instrumental in bringing military aviation to Russia, having followed flying pioneers since Santos-Dumont’s accomplishments in the early 1900s. In addition, Grand Duke Alexander was both cousin (Sandro and Nicholas’s father, Tsar Alexander III, were first cousins) and brother-in-law to the Tsar (his wife was Nicholas’s sister Xenia), enjoying a long, close relationship with Nicholas until the politics surrounding the Empress Alexandra and Rasputin caused a deep rift between the Grand Duke and the Empress during the war. 


                                    Aboard the Yacht Tsarevna on a Visit to Denmark, 1899
                      Tsar Nicholas on Far Left, GD Alexander on Far Right in Naval Uniform



Emboldened by Louis Blériot’s pioneer crossing of the English Channel in 1909, the Grand Duke met with him and Voisin to establish contacts that would further military aviation in Russia. By 1912 Grand Duke Alexander had created an aerodrome and flying school in Sebastopol, where the mild weather favored year-round flying, and had the nascent Imperial Russian Air Service join the army maneuvers of 1912. He held command of the Imperial Russian Air Service in the Great War until 1917. His IRAS was headquartered in Kiev in 1916, in support of the Brusilov offensive.


A Morane-Saulnier Fighter in the
Imperial Russian Air Service, 1915

The revolution saw him and his family exiled to their estate, Ai-Todor, in the Crimea, where they spent more than a year under Soviet detention, until the German occupation of the area after the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk, which proved good fortune and their salvation. The Grand Duke was evacuated in December 1918 by the British destroyer HMS Forsythe to attend the Paris peace conference as the representative of the Romanov family, and his family followed in April 1919 on HMS Marlborough

Throughout the 1920s, spent mostly in France, the Grand Duke sought ways to support his family and to come to terms with their new life. Initially they bought three years by selling his wife’s pearls. In 1925 the Grand Duke was invited to Abyssinia by the Emperor and spent six months there under the auspices of being the Emperor’s emissary to induce the Armenian clergy to return an ancient convent in Jerusalem to Abyssinian control; such was the enduring belief in the power of even a dispossessed Russian royal to exert influence in a changed world.

The Grand Duke toured the United States in 1928 on a lecture tour the theme of which was “Happiness in Poverty”. He had found peace in his writing and living post-revolution, producing several volumes of memoirs, magazine articles, a historical novel based on Catherine the Great, and a book on the lives of exiled European royals, Twilight of Royalty

 Grand Duke Alexander Mikhailovich in Retirement

Here are his comments on the Great War, from his memoir Once A Grand Duke (Garden City Publishing: New York, 1932) —

Nobody has yet written an unbiased account of the last week of the Old World. I doubt that anyone ever will. The information possessed by me and gathered both before and during the war, leads me to believe in the conclusiveness of three facts only:

1. The conflict was caused by the Anglo-German rivalry for the economic supremacy of the world and by the combined efforts of the military cliques of Berlin Vienna, Paris, London and St. Petersburg. Had it not been for the assassination of the Archduke Franz-Ferdinand, another pretext of equally abysmal cynicism would have been chosen by the international champions of war. Kaiser Wilhelm naturally wanted to “have it over with” before the completion of the Russian Military Program in 1917.

2. Nicholas II did all in his power to prevent the outbreak of hostilities, finding but little, if any, support for his conciliatory efforts among his advisers of the Russian Foreign Office and the Russian General Staff.

3. Up to the stroke of midnight, July 31, 1914, the British Government could have averted the catastrophe, had it declared its readiness to stand by France and Russia. A simple declaration made to that effect by Herbert Asquith or Sir Edward Grey would have pacified even the most belligerent Junkers in Berlin. The “Belgian alibi,” advanced by the British Government three days later, made up in human appeal what it lacked in cool logic. The British Empire went to war not because of its holy respect for the inviolability of international treaties but on account of its bitter feelings toward Germany. Were Herbert Asquith less of a lawyer and more of an outspoken humanitarian, no war would have been declared by Germany on August 1, 1914.

All other “ifs” exploited by the historians of 1914 are fanciful and meaningless. We might just as well go back to 1912 and ask ourselves what would have happened to the world if the Republican National Convention in Chicago had nominated Roosevelt instead of Taft. Possibly, the United States would have joined the Allies on May 8, 1915, the morning after the sinking of the Lusitania; more likely, however, Mr. Roosevelt would have recalled the American ambassador to the Court of St. James’s long before that date, as a protest against British interference with the eastbound movements of American merchant ships.

Wednesday, April 8, 2015

Remembering a Veteran: 2Lt Louis Pergaud, 166th R.I., Killed 100 Years Ago Today

Lt Pergaud, Center
Louis Pergaud was a French award-winning writer and soldier, whose principal works were known as "Animal Stories" due to his featuring animals in lead roles. His most notable work was the novel La Guerre des Boutons (The War of the Buttons).

He had done his mandatory military service 12 years before the war and had evolved into a strident anti-cleric, anti-militarist, and pacifist. He responded to the mobilization order with an attempt at registering as a pacifist but was denied. Pergaud was subsequently assigned from the reserves to the 166th Regiment, which was deployed on the Woevre sector, southeast of Verdun.

His misfortune came when he was trapped in barbed wire during an attack, wounded, and taken prisoner by the Germans.  Pergaud was killed on 8 April 1915 when a French shell hit the hospital.

Movie Poster for One of the Films

His literary fame lives on, however, especially due to La Guerre des Boutons. That work is the story of a play war between the children of two villages (the victors take buttons off their opponents as tokens) that escalates into serious fighting.  According to Wikipedia, the novel has been reissued 30 times and has been

Tuesday, April 7, 2015

Zeppelins at War, 1914–1915
Reviewed by Ron Drees



Zeppelins at War, 1914–1915
By Ray L. Rimell
Albatros Productions, Ltd. , 2014


This monograph of a mere 72 pages documents all of the German zeppelins that were built, operated, and lost in the first 17 months of the Great War. Profusely illustrated with photographs, scale drawings, a table listing military zeppelins and a map of Western Front naval bases and army sheds, the author has compiled a remarkable account of waging war with lighter-than-air vessels.

Unidentified Zeppelin on Patrol at Sea Over SMS Seydlitz

The illustrations describe the advances in control surfaces, graceful flights and landings, the immense sheds needed to house 450-foot airships and also the shattered remnants of zeppelins brought down by weather, anti-aircraft fire, bombs dropped by aircraft, and the misfortunes of war. Zeppelins had short lives terminated by violent deaths.

Zeppelins at War is peppered with personal anecdotes of crew members describing wartime assaults on Allied targets, particularly English cities. Other raids are described based on official reports and other documentation. Zeppelins had the advantages of a long range, large bomb loads, and the ability to reach relatively high altitudes but were subject to fog, inclement weather, structural failure, poor navigational capabilities, dud bombs, fragile construction, and fickle and sometimes ferocious winds. Flying a zeppelin was not for the faint of heart.
Purchase Here

Defenses against zeppelins are given some attention in this booklet, but more explanation would be nice. One early method was to fly over a zepp and drop bombs on it. This ignited the hydrogen cells causing the airship to burn furiously and crash. LZ37 in July 1915 suffered just that fate, and the recollection of the lone survivor along with the attacking pilot are highlights of the booklet. So important was this air victory that the King telegraphed the pilot to award him the VC. Attempts would be made to shoot down zepps, but bullets would pass through the gas cells without damaging the aircraft. Eventually it would be realized that without oxygen the hot bullets could not ignite hydrogen. Later ordinance would overcome that problem and zepps would be shot down.

While the author provides much information about individual battles and bomb strikes, he does not comment on the impact zepps had upon the war overall. Perhaps that will come in future booklets. Overall, Zeppelins at War is informative about waging war with zepps, their advantages and difficulties, and their use by the German command. The booklet fills a gap left by other sources which have not covered this subject with nearly as much detail, much less enthusiasm. Highly recommended to anyone interested in the air war from 1914 to 1915.

Ron Drees

Monday, April 6, 2015

The Argonne Cross at Arlington

There are numerous memorials and burials at the Arlington National Cemetery related to the First World War, the most famous, of course, being the Tomb of the Unknowns. We will present these individually on Roads to the Great War.


The inscriptions on the Argonne Cross read: "In memory of our men in France, 1917-1918" (front) and "Erected * Through * The * Efforts * Of * The Argonne * Unit * American * Womens' * Legion" (rear).

Source:  Arlington Cemetery Website

Sunday, April 5, 2015

Raemaekers’s Cartoons: A Special Centennial Event at the National World War I Museum


DRAWN TO WAR: THE POLITICAL CARTOONS OF LOUIS RAEMAEKERS
24 March – 18 October 2015

Dutch artist Louis Raemaekers, described as the “supreme cartoonist of the war", used his pencils as a weapon to create powerful impressions characterizing and criticizing the nature and legacy of war.

Born in the Netherlands in 1869, Raemaekers’s first wartime political cartoon was published in the Amsterdam newspaper De Telegraaf on 1 Aug ust 1914, following the German declarations of war. As is true with today’s political cartoonists, Raemaekers infused religious sensibility and symbolism to develop both comical and stirring commentary on the brutality of war and its destructive legacy. Caricatures of leaders, particularly Kaiser Wilhelm, personified the reprehensible practices of war conducted by Germans while portraying empathy that defied national borders.

Between 1914 and 1918, Raemaekers’s works were printed in newspapers worldwide, reproduced on millions of postcards, published in dozens of books, and exhibited in hundreds of cities around the globe. Raemaekers received unprecedented attention on both sides of the Atlantic, was awarded the Legion of Honor, and received credit for influencing the U.S. decision to enter the war.

“To Your Health, Civilization", 20 September 1914

In one of Raemaekers’s most famous images, he uses a simple composition to deliver a powerful critique of war and to undermine notions of Europe’s perceived progress. The figure of Death drinks from an oversized goblet of blood with which he has toasted Civilization. In Raemaekers's depiction, Death is fattened on Europe’s “civilized” modern warfare. Devoid of national marker, this cartoon points to the shared guilt of European political leaders who, with “enlightenment” and prosperity, started a war that quickly spread across Europe and the world, unleashed massive armies bristling with weapons, and sacrificed millions in the name of enlightenment and national honor.

"Murder on the High Seas: 'Well, Are You Nearly Done?'” 29 July 1915

Almost two years before America's entrance into World War I, Raemaekers’s cartoon published in July of 1915 (alternately titled "The Submarine Butcher") depicts a standoff between a bloody German butcher and a defiant Uncle Sam. The Germans implemented a policy in 1915 of unrestricted submarine warfare on all Allied ships carrying war material, but their policy also put neutral U.S. ships and citizens at risk. The dripping blood represents a series of German submarine attacks on British and U.S. ships carrying American passengers, which sparked a crisis between the U.S. and Germany. Most shocking was the sinking of the British passenger liner Lusitania on 7 May 1915, which killed more than 1,200 civilians, including 124 Americans. The Germans claimed that the ship was carrying war material and, by the necessity of war, had to be attacked. Although the public was not informed at the time, the ship was indeed carrying rifle cartridges and empty shell casings.

More images and details on the show at:
https://theworldwar.org/explore/exhibitions/current-exhibitions/raemaekers
Thanks to Mike Vietti of the National World War I Museum for these images and comments.

Saturday, April 4, 2015

The Centennial at the Grass Roots: Wisconsin's Veterans Museum Honors America's WWI Nurses


A few samples here from the museum's outstanding exhibit and website —

“None complain of the hardships they have been thru and all are anxious to be back on the firing line again.”
-Aimee O’Keefe Kinney in a letter to her sister, 19 September 1918.

Injuries to the arms and lower leg were among the least severe cases. The First World War saw some of the worst wounds imaginable. In particular, artillery and gas caused horrendous damage to soldier’s bodies, and often their minds. When a soldier was injured, first he would be given first aid and then removed from the front line. The soldier was then sent to the battalion aid post. At the battalion aid post, the casualties were given an anti-tetanus shot and a diagnosis tag and sent on to the nearest ambulance dressing station. At this location, first aid and shots were given to those who had not previously received such treatment, and the casualties were then transported to Evacuation Hospitals.

“Madison certainly must be a blue place now that they are notified of the mortalities. We all sympathize with them but the Lord knows we are doing all there is…The most pathetic thing I hurry against is when the boys wake up from ether and find that an arm or leg has been amputated, but like soldiers they bear it bravely.”
- Helen Bulovsky in a letter to her parents, 16–18 October 1918.

"But when I do come home, I’m just going to talk, eat, and sleep for one whole year.”
– Aimee O’Keefe Kinney in a letter to her mother, 19 December 1918.

Aimee O'Keefe, just before her trip home and discharge, 6 April 1919. Most units returned in March, April, and May of 1919. Aimee O’Keefe’s case a typical example. O’Keefe set sail on 13 April, arrived at Hoboken on 23 April, was discharged and allowed to proceed home on 29 April, and formally discharged and issued her final paycheck and bonus on 1 June.

Aimee O’Keefe married Robert Kinney a year later. They had six children together. Aimee O’Keefe Kinney became the commander of the Otis H. King American Legion Post in Hudson, Wisconsin, in 1936. She was the first woman to become a post commander in this state and later became a county commander.


Or, better yet, when you are in Wisconsin visit the museum at:

30 W. Mifflin Street
Madison, WI 53703

Friday, April 3, 2015

Just Ordinary Blokes

These are some of my favorite images of soldiers at ease or posing for the camera, looking like they could be fellows from your neighborhood. Maybe depending on your country, maybe not.












Thursday, April 2, 2015

100 Years Ago: An American Surgeon Goes to War, April 1915



Harvey Williams Cushing is often called the "father of modern neurosurgery" and is also remembered as a distinguished veteran of the Great War. Dr. Cushing saw the war on the Western Front at close quarters first in the early spring of 1915 when he served with a Harvard Unit in the American Ambulance at Neuilly, outside of Paris. He returned to America and advised the preparedness movement on medical matters. Shortly after the entry of the United States into the First World War, Cushing was commissioned as a major in the U.S. Army and served with distinction with both the British Army and the AEF. In the 1930 he published his wartime diary under the title From a Surgeon's Journal. This selection covers his arrival in Paris and the start of of his work at Neuilly 100 years ago.

April 1 , Paris 

It was a poor night, and a most bedraggled group of people made some tea in one of our baskets about 6 a.m. But despite the cold, our first bright clear day brought us cheer; and we finally slid into the Gare d'Orleans, where was breakfast, and a chance to pull ourselves together. Very exciting to look out on the streets of war-time Paris — officers speeding by in motor cars — an armored car with machine guns — ambulances and all else — all in gray war paint except for the red crosses and the red splashes of the old French uniforms. 

Greenough commandeered three big buses into which we clambered, bag and baggage, and set out across the river, through the Place de la Concorde, where Alsace and Lorraine are still draped in black, out along the Elysees, under the Arc to the Porte Maillot, and through it into Neuilly. A very interesting ride on a crisp, clear, spring morning. But the streets seemed very empty for Paris — children playing whip top on the Elysees paths as usual, showing that it was really not Sunday, though it looked it. Everyone not in uniform seems to be garbed in black. 

The converted Lycee Pasteur, now the Ambulance Americaine, is not far from the Porte Maillot, and as we approached it along the Boulevard d'Inkermann it was immediately recognizable: the handsome school building with its courtyard full of Ford motor ambulances, over which a bevy of uniformed drivers — youngsters from home, for the most part — were tinkering, some freshly arrived chassis being newly assembled. A row of patients and nurses waved a welcome from the upper terraces} Blake and others of the permanent staff, most of them in khaki, greeted us below. 

Ambulances and Vehicles at the Lycée

The hospital was quite a revelation, and we met so many people and saw so many familiar faces it 's impossible to set it all down. They have admitted no new cases to our 164 beds — indeed, have emptied them as far as they were able, so that we may have a fairly fresh start. 

The first man we saw had a dreadful paraplegia, with a huge bedsore, due to a section of the spinal cord. He'd been shot in the back by a pointed French bullet — recognizable in the X-ray. In a Frenchman, too! So war is doubly dangerous for the soldier — from behind as well as before. Many other minor cases — none of them very bad — we hurriedly glanced at as we were ushered through the several rooms. No Germans. They would require a guard, and the few they have had in the past did not make them very popular. 

Good Friday, April 2 

It is difficult to say just what are one's most vivid impressions: the amazing patience of the seriously wounded, some of them hanging on for months; the dreadful deformities (not so much in the way of amputations, but broken jaws and twisted, scarred faces); the tedious healing of the infected wounds, with discharging sinuses, tubes, irrigations, and repeated dressings — so much so that grating and painful fractures are simply abandoned to wait for wounds to heal, which they don't seem to do; the risks under apparently favorable circumstances of attempting clean operations, most of which seem to have broken down — a varicocele, an appendix, and, worst of all, a thoracotomy for a bullet in the pericardium which apparently was doing no harm. 

Some of this miscellaneous work savors of "souvenir surgery," and doubtless pressure may oftentimes be brought to bear by the wounded, for they are very proud of these trophies. From the man in question the unoffending bullet, which he wanted as an exhibit to show his visitors, was removed from the pericardial sac; but he got a collapsed left lung, a right pneumonia, then in turn a left pneumonia, and now a bad empyema, with a tube in his side which may or may not close some day. Still he seemed very proud and happy. 

The histories are all interesting, citing, as they do, the man's name, regiment, the place where he received the injury and under what circumstances, how long he had had on his clothes without changing them, where he got his first, second, and possibly third dressing before reaching our ambulance, and so on — each item full of horrible, though fascinating, possibilities. No doubt this will all seem very commonplace after we have been here a few days. 

I was going over a man this afternoon with a facial paralysis from a bullet wound in the mastoid. He got hit during an engagement on September 7 at a place called Croult, and, with a field full of other wounded, was left for dead. The enemy came over them a day or so later; a soldier poked at him and, finding him alive, swung at his head with the butt end of his musket, breaking his jaw. He was finally picked up during a counter-attack and, after a bad otitis media and erysipelas, is now ready — after seven months! — for a nerve anastomosis. It seems hardly worth while, under present circumstances, to attempt cosmetic operations. What's a simple facial paralysis, after all? 

An American-Operated Unit

Then, too, there are those not badly hurt who simulate worse things. For example, one strapping minor officer, a gymnasium instructor in peace time, threw out his chest and made a great fuss about a trifling crackle in his shoulder which Osgood immediately identified as a subacromial bursitis. Many of the men have deformed toes (possibly from sabots?) and they complain that their military shoes are bad, though those we saw seemed sensible enough. But there are other bizarre troubles with the men's feet of really serious nature. There are erythromelalgia-like feet — painful, blue, cold, macerated-looking extremities; and indeed the whole circulatory condition of many of the blesses is very bad. It is presumable that the worst of this is over, with the return of not only dry but warm weather. 

The standing in cold water, even though above the freezing point — one cause of the so-called water-bite — is as bad as frost-bite itself, especially when helped by the too-tight application of puttees which may shrink. Some of these poor devils must have so stood for days in hastily dug trenches without a chance of getting off their boots. 

Almost from the start, the majority of the men have been admitted with bronchitis, and many with influenza-like colds. Then, too, the African troops may have brought with them underlying tropical disorders of which we know little. One of them was a fine Turco in a gay Zouave uniform, with a through-and-through thoracic wound made by a German "ball," the wound of entrance so small it could hardly be found. 

Can you picture him, with no one around he can understand or who can understand him, industriously putting together the biggest and most intricate jig-saw puzzle "made in America" you ever saw, on a table in an American hospital in France, with Americans taking care of him? What can his thoughts of us be? They tell us the Germans don't take the blacks prisoners; but then, what may or may not we believe about all this business? Here we are as near the worst affair in history as Boston is to Worcester, and everyone appears to take it as though it had always been so, and always would be, and meanwhile goes about his own little business unconcernedly. 

Wednesday, April 1, 2015

April Fool: It's World War I

One of our men flew over the Lille aerodrome and dropped a football. All the Germans rushed for cover, imagining that a bomb was coming down, but when, after many enormous rebounds, the ball at length came to rest, they approached it cautiously, on it they read:

April Fool! Gott Strafe England!

Captain P.A. Thompson,  RASC

Thompson is credited with popularizing the expression that disparages British generals of the Great War, "Lions Led by Donkeys", in the English-speaking world. He wrote a much-admired book about the war with that title in 1927.


Tuesday, March 31, 2015

Imperial Germany's "Iron Regiment" of the First World War
Reviewed by Michael Kihntopf


Imperial Germany's "Iron Regiment" of the First World War
By John K. Rieth
Badgley Publishing Company, 2014


German Depiction of Fighting at the Somme
In the past few years there have been numerous books that deal with the German view of World War I. These works have given historians a better rounded knowledge of the Great War. Rieth's book stands head and shoulders above previously published unit histories and should not be ignored for its substantial value in providing the whole picture of many of the war's landmark battles.

John Rieth is a retired U.S. Army lieutenant colonel who brings his considerable experience in military matters to bear in this work. Prior to this work, he authored Patton's Forward Observers, The History of the 7th Field Artillery Observation Battalion. However, this book is a personal endeavor in that it is based on the war observations of his grandfather, who served in the 169 Infantry Regiment from 1914–1915. To that record, Rieth has expertly added excerpts from Otto Lais's book A Machine-gunner in the Iron Regiment (8th Baden Infantry Regiment #169)A, plus the Commemorative Publication for the 1st Regimental Day of the Former 8th Infantry Regiment #169 on 30 and 31 August 1924. The current book is the result of the blending of the three, plus smatterings from other primary sources, and is a treat to read. With a few exceptions, there are no boring, humdrum details that many of us have had to endure in unit histories.


Order Now
Rieth begins with the ancestry of the regiment into which his grandfather was conscripted in 1912 when he was 20 years old. The army had formed the 169 IR during a corps reorganization in 1897, but its roots ran back to battalions that fought in the Napoleonic Wars. Initially it had a nickname of Handwerksburschen (Handworkers) Regiment because most of its soldiers came from the parts of the Grand Duchy of Baden that were known for making jewelry and watches.

Rieth's grandfather's observations provide a very interesting picture of pre-war life in the regiment and also of his reaction to mobilization in August 1914. Thereafter the author, quoting from his grandfather, gives a detailed description of the first real battle of the Great War, Mulhouse, fought on 9 August 1914. Ever after that the regiment was in the forefront of nearly every notable battle on the Western Front. In 1915 it's at Artois and in the Champagne region. In 1916 it's on the Somme and at Serre. There the name of Handwerksburschen was changed to Iron Regiment in tribute to its stand at Serre. In 1917, it's back in Champagne and its 1918 assignments culminate with the Meuse-Argonne offensive facing the Americans.

Anyone who has studied these battles from the English and American perspectives will readily appreciate how Rieth completes the picture of the overall battle. Drawing from Lais's work and the regimental history, he gives the reader a real feel for the preliminary bombardment the 169 IR endured before the first day of battle on the Somme. He also shows how material conditions, but not attitudes, deteriorated after August 1918 when over 1500 men of the division that the regiment was part of were captured. Interestingly enough, this book does not take a pessimistic view of the war except to editorialize on some of the battle orders the regiment was required to carry out. It is a highly personal view of fighting and clearly shows that winning the war to preserve Germany was the regiment's objective.

Don't miss this book. The portion on Mulhouse is a gem, and the description of opposing the Americans' Meuse-Argonne offensive is priceless.

Michael Kihntopf

Image from Tony Langley's Collection

Monday, March 30, 2015

The Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum: A NATIONAL World War I Memorial

Contributed by Courtland Jindra

After World War One, communities large and small throughout the USA struggled with how best to remember their fallen.  Large memorials built by the federal government were very uncommon back then, so local and state leaders took up the slack. Debates raged between those who sought statues or monuments and others who favored “living memorials".

Armistice Day 1918 in Los Angeles

Los Angeles faced much the same quandary. Over twenty three thousand Angelenos had served in the armed forces and within weeks after the Armistice, discussions on how best to honor the troops had become heated.  Eventually, like many municipalities, it opted for both types of memorial.  Early on Exposition Park was chosen as a prime location for what would become southern California's grandest.  Initial thoughts for a living memorial there had been vague. The Los Angeles Times advocated a hospital in an early editorial, but despite some initial interest by stakeholders, that was quickly dropped. Other proposals in the Times included a library with a adjoining museum, a music hall, to building/renaming scores of city streets (the most unusual suggestion was making a lot of sidewalks in the city memorials with readable text every block or so).
  
Many memorials were completed, but the major city project ended up coming down to two finalists. A grand obelisk was proposed for Pershing Square (which was a long time park renamed for the General just a week after the Armistice). This was really a stunning suggestion complete with two base levels on which statues of eight allied commanders would stand. Four 20-foot tall tablets containing the names of all United States war dead were to surround the sides. The structure would have had a viewing platform at the top with a bronze statue of a woman above that, signifying "Victory" (she also would have had a spotlight on her at night). From the top of "Victory" to the bottom of the base level, the memorial would have stood 250 feet over the city (becoming the tallest structure in LA at the time). It was a remarkable set of ideas that this summary can only partially do justice to, and would have contended as the most imposing commemorative structure to the World War built in the US.

The Los Angeles Coliseum Under Construction, 1922

The other finalist was a memorial stadium and amphitheater.  There was no large scale stadium in LA, and the city was already eyeing a bid to host the Olympics. The idea became to marry the two together.  After some debate, the stadium project won approval.  The vast majority of people seemed to think that monuments would be forgotten about, but useful structures would live forever (ironic since many memorial buildings have not lasted).  

The City of Angels was not the only entity to build a stadium as a memorial; several universities did so right after the war (it had become a trendy way to raise money to get new facilities built). Groundbreaking on the Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum began in 1921 on what had been an abandoned horse track and within sixteen months the venue was completed. The impressive architecture was modeled on traditional Roman style and a small piece from the Roman Colosseum flanks the entrance with a rock from Olympia, Greece. The University of Southern California (USC) soon began to use the facility becoming the most well known and longest lasting tenant. In fact, though the State of California owns the Coliseum, in recent years USC was awarded a master lease to manage the property until 2111.

Japanese Contingent, Opening Ceremonies, 1932 Olympics
City leaders were no doubt pleased when the new stadium helped convince the International Olympic Committee to award the 1932 Games to Los Angeles. In the years that followed the Coliseum hosted numerous events, athletic and otherwise. Notable among the the list are two Olympics (the only stadium to ever be so honored), two Super Bowls (including the very first), a World Series, appearances by generals, dignitaries, and statesmen such as George Patton, Omar Bradley, Dwight Eisenhower, Franklin Roosevelt, John Kennedy, Pope John Paul II, and Nelson Mandela.

Super Bowl I, 1967
That is not to say the stated purpose of the facility was forgotten. Annual Armistice (later Veterans) and Memorial Day observances began almost immediately and lasted for decades. At the first Armistice Day ceremony in 1923, the LA Times estimated 100,000 people visited the Exposition Park area to pay tribute. Grand parades of several thousand war heroes, from the Civil War onward, used to march from all around with spectators crowding the roadways. On they went, into the stadium where usually 20,000–30,000 more people sat for the memorial programs.

Given the historic and national nature of the venue, on Veterans Day 1968 the stadium was rededicated, not just to those from LA who served, but to all American WWI veterans. This national distinction is special to the Coliseum as it is one of just a handful of memorials that pay tribute to the entirety of U.S. involvement, and the only stadium that I am aware of. All other memorial stadiums honor city, state, or school war veterans/dead (and/or rededicated to honor multiple wars).

In 1972 ceremonies at the Coliseum suddenly stopped appearing in the LA Times archives. My first thought was it was the divisiveness over Vietnam. However, reading the 12 November 1971  story more closely, I was alerted to the fact that that was the year the government changed both holidays from their traditional observances to three-day weekends. Only 200 people showed up on actual Armistice Day in '71, and it seemed like no one was sure if they should be celebrated on the new days or the traditional ones.  Given no future story was found, I think everyone must have just thrown their hands up and given up. Obviously Veterans Day was moved back to 11 November a few years later, but the damage was apparently done. 

1968 National Dedication Plaque

However, this tradition is being reestablished by current management. Just this past November the Coliseum was opened up to all people to come visit on Veterans Day to ruminate on both the history of the facility and the reason it was constructed. Plans are already in the works for the yearly Memorial and Veterans Day tributes to come back. No one can doubt the impressiveness of the Liberty Memorial in Kansas City, or the sheer size of the Indiana War Memorial district, but it could be argued that no WWI memorial in the States is better known than the Coliseum. As the plaque that resides in the Court of Honor of the peristyle reads, “May the torch of freedom always burn bright.”