Now all roads lead to France and heavy is the tread
Of the living; but the dead returning lightly dance.
Edward Thomas, Roads

Saturday, March 22, 2025

February 1918 News: Harry Lauder Visits the Front and His Son's Grave




Harry Lauder and His Son, John







Harry Chats Up the High Command










Final Resting Place of John Lauder




Sources: I patched this together from multiple online sources, but I could not find the name of the original correspondent. MH

Friday, March 21, 2025

Poilu Léopold Jules Maréchal's Book of Hours of the Great War, Part I: The Manuscript


Le Journal des Tranchées 

Images in This Series Can Be Enlarged
by Clicking on Them

By John Anzalone

In 2010, I acquired at the Hôtel Drouot auction house in Paris a unique relic of the Great War.  Shown above, Le Journal des Tranchées recounts the war memoirs of a soldier who served on the Oise and the Somme fronts for 18 months (1914–1916). Subsequently, he was transferred to a cartography unit behind the lines, where he served until he was demobilized in early 1919.

In every particular, the journal is a deliberate pastiche of a medieval book of hours. Bound in illustrated, incised calf, the book consists of 46 pages of text in calligraphy, with rubricated letters, 38 facing page 5” x 7” watercolors, and as many cartouche drawings in grey wash. The color plates are bordered in gold leaf; all pages are framed in an elaborate barbed wire border.


Title Page


The manuscript gives little personal information about its author, identified only as L. Maréchal. The colophon, however, informs us that its design, calligraphy, layout and binding were completed on 31 December 1926. The painted title page portrays a ghostly figure emerging from thick black smoke as a banner studded with the names of epic battles of the war unfurls. Rising upward, it remains partly attached to the barbed wire that it has ripped loose from its moorings. 

The image can be read as the memorial acknowledgement of the many sacrifices each named battle represents. But it can also be read as a ghastly parody of victory when we notice the cannons hidden within the shroud and the field of crosses on the devastated, blackened battlefield over which that deathly wraith hovers. A similar ambiguity reappears in both the text and the illustrations, emphasizing that this is a less a work of celebration than of commemoration and somber reflection. The colophon on the final page reveals that the book was completed on 31 December 1926 and is wholly the work of a single individual who identifies himself only as “L. Maréchal, artisan.” It is accompanied by a medallion self-portrait. 


Maréchal's Self-Portrait


A Poilu Emerges from Anonymity

The book provides little personal information about the man, but notably, the colophon indicates that more than ten years elapsed between the end of Maréchal’s duty on the front and his completion of this unusual record of it. Exactly who was Maréchal? When and why did he decide to collect in book form the writings and drawings he had made in the trenches? What prompted him to imitate the format and allure of an illuminated book of hours for a war journal? And what were the more salient aspects of his war experiences? 

Despite his authorial identification and the self-portrait, an enigmatic anonymity attaches to Maréchal. Except for his signature and the self-defining reference to him as an “artisan,” the manuscript gives almost no personal information about the man: no mention of any family; no references to his life before the war’s outbreak, and only occasional, brief anecdotes about the comrades in arms he made during their shared hard times. For anyone having a passing familiarity with autobiographical writing of Great War combatants, this near total absence of personal information comes as a surprise.

 What specifics he does provide can be quickly summarized: Maréchal was mobilized on 13 August, 1914 at Sens. With the Battle of the Marne under way, he was sent north with the 168th regiment. It was then divided into smaller units and he was reassigned to the 86th Infantry which was immediately sent due north of Compiègne to the Oise sector, which the Journal describes as “relatively quiet.” Maréchal was to spend the near entirety of his 18 months of combat service there, billeted in the abandoned stone quarries in Montigny/Machemont. These limestone quarries had supplied stone for Haussmann’s reconstruction of Paris in the 1860s and were now empty of usable stone. They were vast enough to sleep hundreds of soldiers and were at a very short distance from the frontline trenches. The manuscript provided precious details of what the quarries looked like as the French army invested them once the war went into the trenches. The watercolor below, dated October 15 (1914), shows Maréchal’s unit arriving at the quarries after a long uphill slog. 


Arrival

Illustrated World War One journals are not so rare as one might imagine. Others have come to light, such as Gaston Lavy’s Ma Grande Guerre, published in facsimile by Flammarion in 2004, but Maréchal’s is a unique example employing the form of an illuminated book of hours. Significantly, such depictions of individual war experiences by otherwise anonymous poilus link the pictorial war memoir to the long, distinguished history of the illustrated book in France that had thrived in the nineteenth century and received a new impetus with the coming of the war. Thanks to new artistic tendencies, innovative printing technologies and the advance of aviation reconnaissance, the Great War stimulated a notable expansion of visual representation. In the quest to represent unprecedented aspects of industrialized warfare, image makers tapped into cubism, war camouflage, and sequential narratives influenced by the nascent cinema. They also injected new vitality into older, traditional forms like the single sheet broadside known as imagerie d’épinal.

But whether they were looking back on the traditions of their craft or forward to newer trends, illustrators were also participating in the historicizing of the war, relating the narratives of 1914–18 to earlier wars and to the history of war imagery itself. Attempts to connect the history of the Great War in real time to the history of French warfare and of France itself abound in WW I illustration. They participate in the rhetoric of propaganda, of course, but they once again represent an attempt to make sense of a present many found incomprehensible by reaching back to a seemingly more coherent past. It is this tradition Maréchal has tapped into. His is among the numerous works that allude in both form and substance to the chivalry and panache of the medieval and renaissance periods, and earlier victorious combats in order to assert a noble genealogy for the poilu. The great Books of Hours of the middle ages served Maréchal well, allowing his memorial to echo the solemn, even exalted history of France at its foundation. The choice of this format for his memoir hints as well at his unusual level of education and his cultural fluency, something that could only be confirmed once we had a better sense of his biography.

It took two years of archival digging for that more detailed picture of Maréchal’s life to emerge—and here I wish to acknowledge the collaboration of Bernard Lambot, a former police detective,  and the late Lucette Lambot, a professional archivist, whose dogged pursuit of this elusive man in recruiting station archives across the Ile de France is responsible for all that we are ever likely to know about him. 


On Observation Duty


Léopold Jules Maréchal was born on 21 November 1882, an only child, who lost his father at the age of 14. In 1902 he had his first, brief experience of military service in the 37th, then the 104th infantry regiments before being declared exempt from military service as the only child of a widowed mother. In 1909 he married a teacher named Eugénie Zeckel. His mother died in July of 1914 scant weeks before he was mobilized at the age of 32. A few months later, on 12 December, his wife succumbed to septicemia soon after giving birth to a daughter named Suzanne. This occurred while Maréchal is at the front at Machemont, yet he makes no mention of the loss of his wife or the birth of his child in the manuscript. A few years after the end of the Great War, he remarried.  

He exercised the profession of illustrator/engraver throughout his professional life. The quality of his French and the sophistication of several other paintings that have turned up suggest that in some respects he must have received a classical education. Around 1950, the Maréchals retired and moved from Paris to Jouques in the Bouches du Rhône near Marseille. A few now quite elderly inhabitants there still remember the profile of a slightly built gentleman whom people called “le Parisien,” a self-effacing, discrete, even aloof man who spent his time drawing, painting, and walking in the countryside. 

Léopold Maréchal died on Christmas Day 1964, his wife ten years later on 11 December1974. Upon inheriting her parents’ estate Suzanne Maréchal, who was then living in Africa, entrusted the sale of its contents to a local brocanteur or secondhand dealer. As far as we have been able to determine, Le Journal des tranchées disappeared from view with the dispersion of Maréchal’s estate in 1975. We lose track of it there and have no idea of its whereabouts before it came up for auction on Tuesday 10 March 2010. 

Next:  In Part II of this series, to be presented on 28 March 2025, Maréchal's war service with be examined.

3 April 25 NEWS!  The entire manuscript of Journal Des Tranchées  can now be viewed online HERE (in 4 sections) thanks to JSTOR.org.


About Our Contributor

John Anzalone is Professor of French and Media/Film Studies, Emeritus at the Department of World Languages and Literatures, Skidmore College, Saratoga Springs NY

Contact John at: janzalon@skidmore.edu


Thursday, March 20, 2025

The Unsinkable Molly Brown Goes to War


Margaret "Molly" Tobin Brown

Margaret Tobin  was born to Irish immigrants John and Johanna Tobin in 1867 in Hannibal, Missouri. (Margaret did not become commonly known as "Molly" until after her 1933 death).  The Tobins were part of a wave of immigration following the first period of industrialization in America. Margaret—with  her brother Daniel—followed the family's and the nation's "head west" impulse and moved to Leadville, Colorado, in 1885.

There she met  and married miner J. J. Brown, who struck gold. J. J. and Margaret became millionaires. They moved to Denver in 1894, where Margaret—a born reformer—became involved in politics, philanthropy,  and the progressive movement. The couple became world travelers but drew apart. In 1909, after 23 years of marriage, the Browns quietly signed a separation agreement that left her financially independent.

On a 1912 trip, Margret received  news of her ill grandson that hastened Margaret’s return, and she booked passage on the first available ship, the Titanic. Her stellar efforts to encourage her fellow survivors and raise funds for the less fortunate passengers has become part of American folklore. Titanic survivor Margaret Tobin Brown has been known since as "The Unsinkable Molly Brown."

Margaret Presenting an Award of Appreciation to the Captain
 of RMS Carpathia for Rescuing the Titanic Survivors


What is forgotten (for the most part) is Margaret's dedicated work in the Great War.  Arriving back in Colorado as a nationally recognized figure, she worked hard to relieve the suffering of striking Colorado miners and for womens' suffrage, and even made an unsuccessful run at a seat in the U.S. Senate.

However, when World War I broke out, Margaret shifted her focus to relief efforts, eventually traveling to France where she worked with the American Committee for Devastated France to help rebuild ravaged areas behind the front line and with the Red Cross to aid wounded French and American soldiers. (The Chateau of Blerancourt, a French-American museum north of Paris, has a commemorative plaque that bears her name.) Her son, Lawrence, served in the U.S. Army during the war and was gassed in the assault on the Hindenburg Line by the U.S. 30th Division on 29 September 1918.


Margaret's Doughboy Son, Larry Brown


For her work during the war and her overall good citizenship, including her efforts with the Titanic survivors and the Juvenile Court of Denver, Margaret Brown was awarded the French Legion of Honor in 1932. Something of a mythic figure (always as Molly Brown), she's had a Disney riverboat, a Gemini spacecraft, and a museum named after her, portrayed frequently in TV and film accounts of the Titanic disaster, and even had her own Broadway musical, The Unsinkable Molly Brown.

Sources:  Over the Top, April 2012; Molly Brown House Museum; Visit Denver Blog; Retrospect Journal

Six Notable Prisoners of War

 

President of France, Charles de Gaulle


Once recovered from two wounds suffered in the early fighting, de Gaulle rejoined his regiment first as company commander, then as aide to the colonel. He was wounded a third time during the battle of Verdun, at Douaumont, in 1916. Left for dead, he was given a "posthumous" mention in army dispatches. He was, in fact, captured and received hospital treatment in Mainz before being imprisoned in various locations, including the fortress of Ingolstadt in Bavaria. After five failed escape bids, he was moved frequently and not freed until the Armistice. 


Soviet Marshal, Mikhail Tukhachevsky



During the first half-year of the war Tukhachevsky was rewarded with six decorations for personal courage. In February 1915 he was captured by German troops and tried to escape four times. While being imprisoned in the Bavarian fortress of Ingolstadt, where the most obstinate and dangerous captives were kept, Tukhachevsky met the then captain Charles de Gaulle, future Resistance hero and French president. His fifth attempt to escape was a success and he managed to return to Russia in October 1917 when the Bolshevik revolt was in full swing.


Air Innovator Roland Garros


When the war erupted, Garros, already famous, joined the French air service and was posted to a squadron near Nancy. There he took on the task of devising a method of shooting down the enemy. On 18 April 1915, the fuel line of his Morane Saulnier Type G became clogged, causing engine trouble. He came down in German-controlled territory where he was grabbed by alert German Infantrymen. Garros spent three years as a prisoner of war before escaping in early 1918. He insisted on returning to combat, but after three years he was not the same man—he was weaker, older, and needed glasses. Moreover, aircraft had improved dramatically in speed and capability. Nonetheless, Garros insisted. Now flying a Spad XIII, he shot down another German and was then shot down himself on 5 October 1918. This time he did not survive the crash.


Revolutionary and America's Favorite Communist,

 Josip Broz (Tito)


Josip Broz was drafted into the Austro-Hungarian army in 1913, completed non-commissioned officer training, and was sent as a sergeant in the war against Serbia in 1914. Transferred to the Russian front in early 1915, he was seriously wounded and captured by the Russians in April 1915. After a long hospitalization he was sent to prisoner-of-war camps, where he became acquainted with Bolshevik propaganda. He managed to escape his last camp and make his way to Petrograd (St. Petersburg). In 1917 he participated in the July Days demonstrations and, after the October Revolution, joined a Red Guard unit in Omsk, Siberia.  In the photo above, the former prisoner of war is shown on a 1971 visit to the White House with President Richard Nixon.


Musical Showman, Maurice Chevalier



In the first weeks of combat a shrapnel shell exploded in Chevalier’s trench, hitting his chest, and entering his lung. “Then it was, as the English Tommies used to say, that I got my packet.” He recalls the pain, blood oozing from his mouth, and soldiers carrying him to a village behind the lines. The next day the Germans took the village: those too badly injured to move, including Chevalier, were captured. Chevalier was in hospital at Magdeburg before being moved to Altengrabow prison camp. “That was a bitter experience for discipline was strict,” he later said. He feared the injury had ruined his singing voice, but he was relieved to find he could still entertain his fellow prisoners. Through a complex deception involving his Folies Bergère girlfriend, Mistinguett, the neutral King of Spain, and his own forgery skills, Chevalier was reclassified as an ambulance worker eligible for a prisoner exchange program. After two years and four months as a prisoner of war, Chevalier was free. He returned to Paris and was declared unfit to carry out further war service. He was discharged and awarded the Croix de Guerre.


Aerial Explorer, Gunther Plüschow



After an epic escape from the siege of the German colony at Tsing Tao, naval aviator Plüschow subsequently became the only German to escape from a British Prisoner of War camp in either World War. His capture in Gibraltar in 1915 terminated his epic Nanking-Shanghai-Nagasaki-Honolulu-San Francisco self-extraction from the Asian theater.  After his Gibraltar capture, he again demonstrated his remarkable escape skills. After promptly departing his Leicestershire prisoner of war camp, Plüschow made his way to London, where he worked and spent time visiting the British Museum, eventually slipping aboard a ship bound for the Netherlands, from where he snuck back into Germany to resume his duties with the German Navy.

Wednesday, March 19, 2025

Remembering a Veteran: Listen to an Interview with the Cowboy Ace, Capt. Fred Libby, RFC, US Air Service


Fred Libby—Cowboy and Aviator

Frederick Libby was born in the early 1890s in Sterling, Colorado. He worked as an itinerant cowboy during his youth and joined the Canadian Army shortly after the outbreak of World War I. Deployed to France in 1915, Libby initially served with a motor transport unit, then volunteered for the Royal Flying Corps. He served as an observer with No. 23 Squadron and No. 11 Squadron, then as a pilot with No. 43 Squadron and No. 25 Squadron. Scoring 10 confirmed aerial victories as an observer-machine gunner on a Royal Aircraft Factory F.E.2b (Farman Experimental) during his RFC career, he became the first American fighter ace. Libby transferred to the United States Army Air Service in 1917 and was medically discharged soon after for spondylitis. As a civilian, he went on to embark on a number of business ventures, including founding the Eastern Oil Company and Western Air Express. Libby passed away in 1970. 


How an F.E.2b Observer Dealt with a Rear Attack


This March 1962 interview was part of an oral history series conducted by the American Fighter Aces Association at the Museum of Flight in Washington State. It covers his first days of air combat in the Great War over the Somme battlefield.  The interviewer was Commander Eugene A. Valencia, Jr., USN, an ace himself in World War II. To access the recording (and transcript) of the interview click HERE.

Thanks to our Assistant Editor Kimball Worcester for discovering this interview.



Tuesday, March 18, 2025

Britain and Italy in the Era of the Great War: Defending and Forging Empires

 

British Tommies on the Italian Front with an
Italian Soldier and Civilian Volunteers

Tomlinson Prize, 2021

By  Stefano Marcuzzi
Cambridge University Press, 2022


This is an important reassessment of British and Italian grand strategies during the First World War. Stefano Marcuzzi sheds new light on a hitherto overlooked but central aspect of Britain and Italy's war experiences: the uneasy and only partial overlap between Britain's strategy for imperial defence and Italy's ambition for imperial expansion. 

Taking Anglo-Italian bilateral relations as a special lens through which to understand the workings of the Entente in World War I, he reveals how the ups-and-downs of that relationship influenced and shaped Allied grand strategy. 

Marcuzzi considers three main issues—war aims, war strategy and peace-making—and examines how, under the pressure of divergent interests and wartime events, the Anglo-Italian traditional friendship" turned increasingly into competition by the end of the war, casting a shadow on Anglo-Italian relations both at the Peace Conference and in the interwar period.
From: U.S. Dept of Commerce Library


Click HERE to Order


There is in Anglophone discourse and in particular in Anglo-American historiography, a long tradition of belittling and running down post-Risorgimento Italy's quest for Great Power status. From Lord Salisbury's ‘sturdy beggars’ to Richard Bosworth's telling description "the least of the great powers," post-1861 Italy has been seen, as in the words of Prince Bismarck, suffering from ‘a big appetite but bad teeth’. In his book, Britain and Italy in the era of the Great War: defending and forging empires, Stefano Marcuzzi seeks to challenge this narrative for the period between Italy's involvement in the Great War to the Treaty of Versailles. Marcuzzi aims to show that during this era "Britain was Italy's main partner within the Entente and that Rome sought to make London the guarantor of the promises upon which Italy joined the Allies" (p. 2).

According to Marcuzzi, Italian governing elites, especially the Italian prime minister at the time, Antonio Salandra, and his foreign minister, Sidney Sonnino, "assumed that Britain and Italy enjoyed special geopolitical, economic, cultural and historical ties" (p. 2). In his subsequent narrative, Marcuzzi uses a detailed analysis of primary sources on Anglo-Italian diplomatic interaction in the period to argue that "the geopolitical goals of Britain and Italy, which seemed compatible and even mutually supportive, grew irreconcilable by the end of the war."
From: International Affairs, Volume 97, Issue 4


Monday, March 17, 2025

The McMahon Letter of 24 October 1915

 


Sir Henry McMahon (1862–1949), British High Commissioner in Cairo, negotiated in 1915–16 with Husain Ibn Ali, the Sherif of Mecca. The British government promised to support his bid for the restoration of the Caliphate (and leadership in the Arab world).

The Hussein-McMahon correspondence was later contradicted by the Sykes-Picot Agreement, a secret agreement between Britain and France that divided the Middle East after the war, and the Balfour Declaration, which supported the establishment of a Jewish homeland in Palestine. This became a point of contention, with Arabs arguing that the British had betrayed their promises, lasting up to today. Below is the key letter in the correspondence. In 1916, T.E. Lawrence was posted to Hejaz, in modern Saudi Arabia, to work with the Hashemite forces. For most of his service time in the desert he believed he was working in accordance with the policies implied in McMahon's letter.

[To: Husain Ibn Ali, the Sherif of Mecca]

October 24, 1915.

I have received your letter of the 29th Shawal, 1333, with much pleasure and your expression of friendliness and sincerity have given me the greatest satisfaction.

I regret that you should have received from my last letter the impression that I regarded the question of limits and boundaries with coldness and hesitation; such was not the case, but it appeared to me that the time had come when that question could be discussed in a conclusive manner.

I have realised, however, from your last letter that you regard this question as one of vital and urgent importance. I have, therefore, lost no time in informing the Government of Great Britain of the contents of your letter, and it is with great pleasure following statement, which I am confident you will receive with satisfaction. 

The two districts of Mersina and Alexandretta and portions of Syria lying to the-west of the districts of Damascus, Homs, Hama.and Aleppo cannot be said to be purely Arab, and should be excluded from the limits demanded.

With the above modification, and without prejudice to our existing treaties with Arab chiefs, we accept those limits.

As for those regions lying within those frontiers wherein Great Britain is free to act without detriment to the interest of her ally, France, I am empowered in the name of the Government of Great Britain to give the following assurances and make the following reply to your letter:-

(1) Subject to the above modifications, Great Britain is prepared to recognise and support the independence of the Arabs in all the regions within the limits demanded by the Sherif of Mecca.

(2) Great Britain will guarantee the Holy Places against all external aggression and will recognise their inviolability.

(3) When the situation admits, Great Britain will give to the Arabs her advice and will assist them to establish what may appear to be the most suitable forms of government those various territories.

(4) On the other hand, it is understood that the Arabs have decided to seek the advice and guidance of Great Britain only, and that such European advisers and officials as may be required for the formation of a sound form of administration will be British.

(5) With regard to the vilayets of Bagdad and Basra, the Arabs will recognise that the established position and interests of Great Britain necessitate special administrative arrangements in order to secure these territories from foreign aggression to I am convinced that this declaration will assure you beyond all possible doubt of the sympathy of Great Britain towards the aspirations of her friends the Arabs and will result in a firm and lasting alliance, the immediate results of which will be the exp I have confined myself in this letter to the more vital and important questions, and if there are any other matters dealt with in your letters which I have omitted to mention, we may discuss them at some convenient date in the future.

It was with very great relief and satisfaction that I heard of the safe arrival of the Holy Carpet and the accompanying offerings which, thanks to the clearness of your directions and the excellence of your arrangements, were landed without trouble or mis I am sending this letter by the hand of your trusted and excellent messenger, Sheikh Mohammed ibn Arif ibn Uraifan, and he will inform you of the various matters of interest, but of less vital importance, which I have not mentioned in this letter.

(Compliments).

(Signed): A. HENRY MCMAHON.


See our earlier article on the Arab Revolt HERE.


Source:  The Husain-McMahon Letters (excerpt), The McMahon Letter, From The Israel-Arab Reader, (3rd Ed.) edited, Walter Laqueur, Bantam Books, 1976.

Sunday, March 16, 2025

Rogers’ Rangers in the Great War


Badge of the 20th Battalion, CEF


James Patton

Rogers' Rangers were raised in 1755 in the Province of New Hampshire by the then self-styled  Major Robert Rogers (1731–1795) to serve with the British during the Seven Years War (aka French and Indian War). Rogers was inspired by the reputation and the unconventional tactics of the Indian fighter Benjamin Church (1639-1718). His command was to be rapidly deployable light infantry, tasked mainly with reconnaissance, ambushes and  hit-and-run raids. In 1759 he codified their tactics as his 28 Rules of Ranging. His Rangers grew to over a dozen companies, totaling over 1,200 men at the peak, who were the best scouts the British had in the upper Hudson country. No longer needed after the French surrender in 1760, they were discharged, however Maj. Rogers remained in service until 1765. 

During the American Revolution, Rogers re-constituted his outfit as a Loyalist unit, calling it the Queen’s  Rangers (“Queens”), which operated from 1775 to 1783. The unit received the honorary appellation ” 1st Americans” from the king in 1779. Following the end of the war,  a group commanded by Lieut. Col. John Simcoe (1752–1806), set up their base in Upper Canada (today’s Ontario) and were known first as Simcoe’s Rangers, then the York Militia and later the York Rangers (“Yorks”), with active service in 1793–1802, 1812–15,1837–38, then finally 1866 to date. 

A group of the Queen’s not under Simcoe remained in British service in New Brunswick  until disbanded in 1793. After WWI,  a new militia regiment was created from the 35th CEF which was named the West Toronto Regiment in 1921. After amalgamation with the 2nd Battalion of the Yorks in 1925, this unit was allowed to revive the name of the Queen’s. Subsequently, in 1927 this unit was also allowed to reclaim the appellation “1st Americans.” Finally, in 1936, this new Queen’s Rangers (1st Americans) were amalgamated with the Yorks to form today’s unit, the Queens York Rangers (1st American Regiment) (“QYR”). 



Thus the strongest claim to the heritage of Rogers’ Rangers belongs to this Toronto-based regiment, which has a direct line from Rogers’ second creation. Not currently serving as rangers, their current role is Light Armored Vehicle reconnaissance. 


The Great War Comes

By 1915 it had become apparent that the Western Front wasn’t going to be a ranger kind of war—it was going to be a Napoleonic cataclysm of big units engaging in big battles. The legacy of Rogers’ Rangers would extend into the Great War, but not as rangers. 

The Canadian Militia was limited to home service, so just as for the Boer War, an overseas service force was created.  This Canadian Expeditionary Force (CEF) had to be made up of standard British 960-man battalions and the Militia "regiments" were unsuitable building blocks because they varied widely in size and training. So their members were urged to enlist individually into new CEF battalions. Conveniently, this way all would serve under the same terms and conditions. Over the years men from the Yorks joined the 20th, 35th, 127th, and 220th  CEF battalions.

The 20th  (Central Ontario) Battalion CEF was authorized on 7 November 1914, mostly with men from the Yorks. They went overseas on 15 May 1915 and on to France on 15 September 1915. They fought in France and Flanders as a part of the 4th Canadian Infantry Brigade, 2nd Canadian Division. Until he was wounded in late 1917, the commander of the 20th was Lieut. Col. C.H. "Herman" Rogers OBE (1876–1946), a regular cavalryman who came over from the 3rd Prince of Wales Canadian Dragoons (he brought his horse with him), and he was a direct descendant of Maj. Robert Rogers. 


Lt. Col. Rogers


The 20th's battle honors include the Battle of the Somme (1916), Vimy  Ridge, Passchendaele (1917),  Hill 70, Amiens, the Scarpe, Canal du Nord, Canal de l'Escaut and the Pursuit to Mons (1918). Two of its members, Lieut. Wallace Lloyd Algie and Sgt. Frederick Hobson, were posthumously awarded the Victoria Cross (VC).

Four thousand three hundred ten officers and men served in the 20th—843 (19.6%) were killed in action or died of wounds, 1,855 (43%) were wounded, and 91 died due to disease or accidents. Only 22 were ever taken prisoner—nine of them from a stretcher party that got lost at Passchendaele—and there was only one deserter. All of these battle honors and the heritage of the 20th  CEF, including the VCs, are now attributed to the QYR.

As was the practice in the CEF, the 35th and the 220th supplied replacements, while the 127th became a railway unit. 


Officers of the 20th Battalion


The Descendants of Rogers' Ranger

Who else claims descent from Rogers’ Rangers? How about American rangers? In the 19th century there were U.S. units that operated sort of  like rangers, especially including two that were CSA, but all were short-lived. Today’s U.S. Army’s  Rangers, including the 75th Infantry and Ft. Benning’s Ranger School come to mind, but their history begins with Darby’s Rangers in 1942, who trained as British Commandos, not rangers. Instead their claim is based on being the repository for the ranger legacy in American service  (actually Rogers’ Rangers were in British service). Claiming that they are the true successors to the 1755–61 Rangers (not the Loyalist ones), they have embraced both the ranger ethos and a modern set of the Ranger Rules, outlined in U.S. Army publication TC 3-21.76 26 April 2017. 

Another American claim arises from an ad hoc local militia unit raised by Maj. Rogers to fight in Pontiac’s War (1763–65), which, although also in British Service, is regarded as the progenitor of the Michigan National Guard.  

What made a soldier a Ranger? The full text of Rogers’ 28 Rules can found HERE.

Perhaps thanks to Rogers, the term "Ranger" has long sported a certain cachet. Over the years, in British or Canadian service, it has been used by several other units that were not descended from Rogers’ Rangers and didn’t use ranger tactics. Right now there are the following:

The Rangers, a British regiment created in 2021. They aren’t rangers; their mission is to advise and train foreign partners in unconventional warfare, akin to the the U.S. Army’s Special Forces (“Green Berets”).


Historic Battle Flag of the Queen's York Rangers


The Rocky Mountain Rangers (RMR), formed in 1908 in British Columbia. Light infantry today rather than rangers, its members served in WWI with the 172nd (Rocky Mountain Rangers) Batttalion CEF. Before the 172nd CEF was broken up in 1917, they had received a set of colors from Princess Patricia of Connaught.  Due to the participation of its soldiers in the battles of Arras 1917 and 1918, Hill 70, Ypres 1917, Amiens, the Hindenburg Line, and Valenciennes, the RMR displays those honors today. 

The Canadian Rangers are a para-military unit formed in 1942. Made up of local residents  who can be called  upon to perform security, surveillance and search/rescue duties in the Far North, they carry bolt action rifles—until 2018 the venerable .303 Lee-Enfield No. 4.   




Saturday, March 15, 2025

80th Division in the Meuse-Argonne—A Nifty Five-Star Little Documentary



This video is a semi-chronological compilation of Army Signal Corps films of the 80th Blue Ridge Division around the time of the Meuse-Argonne Offensive. Nevertheless, it is well worth a look. The actual battle scenes—less than a quarter of the film—are gripping. These include the troops moving through captured territory past disabled artillery and dead enemy soldiers (see image above), the destruction around the village of Béthincourt—an early objective for the division—and a machine gun unit cautiously advancing through a forest to set up their guns. A herd of mules interrupting the Doughboys' advance makes an amusing appearance.

The non-combat sequences are also surprisingly interesting. Live-fire training on machine guns, rifle grenades, and mortars is shown. The best episode involves a visit by General Pershing to Division Headquarters. He is clearly pleased with the performance of the Blue Ridge boys, not at all in his reportedly frequent kick-ass-and-take-numbers frame of mind. Overall, this is a film for real AEF connoisseurs; it has a gritty and authentic "You Are There" feel to it.

Sources: YouTube


Friday, March 14, 2025

Thomas Hardy's Poetic Curse


British Poster from the Interwar Period


I was recently reading some of Thomas Hardy's war poems, which tend to be pretty pessimistic. The selection I found most memorable, though, was this curse against the warmakers from "Moments of Vision."


Then seemed a Heart crying: 'Whosoever they be 

At root and bottom of this, who flung this flame 

Between kin folk kin tongued even as are we, 


'Sinister, ugly, lurid, be their fame; 

May their familiars grow to shun their name, 

And their brood perish everlastingly'. 

April 1915

Thursday, March 13, 2025

Megiddo: Biblical Site of a Decisive World War I Battle


Ruins of Ancient Tel Mediggo


We have previously presented articles on General Allenby' 1918 victory at the Battle of Megiddo HERE and HERE. Located in a valley commonly called Armageddon in modern times, Megiddo was a powerful city-state in Canaan during the 4th, 3rd, and 2nd millennia BC. Before the 20th Century, it was located at the crossing of two trade and military routes.  In this article we examine the Biblical and some historical references to that battlefield. There's reason why the Book of Revelation places the final battle between Good and Evil there, suggests Professor Eric Cline of George Washington University.


The Apocalypse. Judgment Day. 

The End of Times. 

Armageddon.


The Valley Today

Students of the Bible know it as the place where the cataclysmic battle between the forces of good and the forces of evil will unfold. Many believe that this battle will take place in the very near future, but few know that Armageddon is a real place—one that has seen more fighting and bloodshed than any other spot on earth.

Armageddon is a corruption of the Hebrew Har Megiddo and means literally "the mount of Megiddo." During the past 4000 years, at least 34 bloody conflicts have already been fought at the ancient site of Megiddo and adjacent areas of the Jezreel Valley. Egyptians, Canaanites, Israelites, Midianites, Amalekites, Philistines, Hasmonaeans, Greeks, Romans, Muslims, Crusaders, Mamlukes, Mongols, French, Ottomans, British, Australians, Germans, Arabs, and Israelis have all fought and died here. [The first recorded battle here—fought with chariots—was an Egyptian victory over the Canaanits.] The names of the warring generals and leaders reverberate throughout history: Thutmose III, Deborah and Barak, Sisera, Gideon, Saul and Jonathan, Shishak, Jehu, Joram, Jezebel, Josiah, Antiochus, Ptolemy, Vespasian, Saladin, Napoleon, and Allenby, to name but a few of the most famous.

Throughout history, Megiddo and the Jezreel Valley have been Ground Zero for battles that determined the very course of civilization. It is no wonder that the author of Revelation believed Armageddon, the penultimate battle between good and evil, would also take place in this region!

Megiddo, a fascinating site of twenty cities built directly on top of one another and inhabited continuously from 3000 to 300 BC, lies at a strategic junction of roads running north-south and east-west. Whoever had control of Megiddo had control of one of the major trade routes of antiquity, the Via Maris (the "Way of the Sea") Wending its way directly through Israel, right past Megiddo in the Jezreel Valley, this strategically placed road ran between Egypt in the south and Mesopotamia (modern Iran/Iraq) or Anatolia (modern Turkey) in the north. Virtually every invading army that came through this region during the past 4000 years fought battles for control of Megiddo and the Jezreel Valley. The only exception was the army of Alexander the Great, who didn't have to fight because the area surrendered to him first.

One lesson that can be learned from the history surrounding the area is the importance of maintaining a strategic presence on military and/or mercantile routes. We also see that, while weapons and technology have changed over the millennia, the strategies and tactics frequently have not. Often the strategies used in the battles fought at such places are repeated by different commanders and different armies in different eras. Finally, we learn that, probably as a result of the necessity of occupying such strategic positions, certain areas of the world have seen consistent fighting for literally millennia.


Australian Light Horse
Assembled for Armageddon, 1918

There were so many battles in this little valley, which measures only 20 miles long by seven miles wide, that one might paraphrase Sir Winston Churchill and say "never in the field of human conflict have so many fought so often over so little space!"

Source: "The Battles of Armageddon," Neil Dearberg, The Bible and Interpretation, December 2001

Wednesday, March 12, 2025

The Evolution of American War Planning Versus Germany


Elihu Root, Secretary of War and State
(1845–1937)


By Colonel Adlof Carlson, U.S. Army

The Army and the Navy Must Be Friends

At the 1904 War College dedication speech, reform-minded Secretary of War Elihu Root encouraged the Army and Navy “never to forget your duty of coordination . . . this is the time to learn to serve together without friction.” The final ingredient in tying together the Army and Navy’s efforts was the 1903 creation of the Joint Army and Navy Board, the first standing inter-service war planning association in American history. The board consisted of four principal officers of each service, with Admiral Dewey, revered hero of Manila Bay, as chair until his death in 1917. The board’s function was to issue broad guidelines for the defense of the United States, its possessions, and the Western Hemisphere. Detailed planning was the responsibility of the General Staff and the Navy Staffs, with most of the actual work done by the two war colleges.

By the early 20th century, the danger of war with Germany was real. In the first three months of 1899, a combined Anglo-American force had appeared in Samoan waters to overthrow a native government installed by the Germans. This force began to shell areas considered friendly to German rule, and later landed a force which suffered seven casualties in fighting German supported Samoans, the first blood shed in German-American hostilities. 

Bad feelings began to grow between the two countries. The Washington Post editorialized that: 

We know that by a thousand unmistakable signs and by the experience of years that in the German government the United States has a sleepless and insatiable enemy. 

In April 1904, in response to a recommendation made by Army Chief of Staff Lieutenant General Adna R. Chaffee, Secretary of War William Howard Taft directed the Joint Army Navy Planning Board to:

Agree upon a series of practical problems (taking them in the order of their assumed importance) which involve cooperation of the services, and for the execution of which in time of emergency the two staffs will be responsible.

The Joint Board’s solutions to these “practical problems” would become war plans signed by the two service secretaries. This was the first joint deliberate planning system in American history.

Admiral Dewey directed the chiefs of the two war colleges, Admiral Henry C. Taylor and General Tasker H. Bliss, to submit recommendations on how best to get the study underway.42 Bliss submitted a 21-page paper, which shaped American war plans for the next 30 years. He assumed that the enforcement of the Monroe Doctrine, which he pointed out at the time of the War with Spain was the “only” American foreign policy, would be the most probable cause of America’s future wars. Significantly, Bliss reasoned that the acquisition of the Philippines expanded the Monroe Doctrine beyond the American hemisphere. He concluded that the major European powers would not likely attack the United States itself because diversion of military resources would weaken them in the face of continental rivalries; and that the real purpose of any violation of the Monroe Doctrine would be to seize American possessions in our hemisphere or in the Philippines.  Accordingly, Bliss’s paper recommended that the two services study the following problems in this order:

1. U.S. intervention in a South American country to assist the government in ousting a foreign power supporting insurgents;

2. U.S. at war against two continental European powers [one of which was sure to be Germany];

3. U.S. at war against a coalition of Britain and Canada; and,

4. U.S. intervention into Mexico “with another foreign complication” [presumably a European power collecting Mexican debt].

The most virulent of all the potential enemies analyzed by the Joint Board was Germany. Accordingly, in 1913, these studies led to the formal plan BLACK, for war between the United States and Germany. Thus, when hostilities broke out in Europe in 1914, the United States had already contemplated the possibility of war, and had developed plans for the employment of its military forces for the defense of its territory and the enforcement of the Monroe Doctrine, territorially expanded to encompass its new Pacific holdings. It remained an open question, however, as to whether the country possessed the means to achieve these objectives.

This first version of War Plan Black, however, did not contemplate deploying an American army to Europe. It saw the main threat from Germany to be naval incursions against North America and in the Pacific.


Dewey—Hero of Manila Bay

The Impact of the World War

At the time of President Wilson’s first inauguration, in 1913, the country faced two crises in foreign affairs. The first was the murder of Francisco Madero, Diaz’ successor in Mexico. Wilson, who regarded Madero as his ideological counterpart, became the uncompromising opponent of Madero’s murderer, Victoriano Huerta.

At about the same time, the California state legislature passed the Alien Exclusion Act, which forbade Japanese nationals from owning or leasing land in that state. The Japanese government, which refused to believe that the Federal government could not overturn a state law, was incensed, and began to take advantage of what they saw as a convergence of interests with Mexico.

In the spring and summer of 1913, Japan supplied arms to the Huerta government. Then, in May, England recognized the Huerta government in order to secure a steady supply of Mexican oil to fuel the warships of the Royal Navy.

These developments moved the Army-Navy Joint Planning Board to act. What the Board did was based upon the conclusion that the country could not defeat any hostile force landed on the west coast. One analysis read:

If 200,000 men of any first class hostile power should be landed on our Pacific Coast, we should have no course but to hand over to a foreign nation the rich empire west of the Rockies, with its cities, its harbors, and the wealth of its valleys and mountains.

In November 1914, the Japanese embarked on a series of campaigns in Asia and the Pacific, ostensibly in support of their British allies, but which in reality were designed to take advantage of Germany’s predicament to extend Japan’s empire. The German port of Tsingtao, as well as the Marshalls, the Caroline, and the Mariana Islands were captured, which worsened the already precarious strategic situation in the Philippines.

The situation on the sea lanes also put Americans and American interests at risk. The German High Seas Fleet, bottled up in the North Sea, was little danger, but the German submarine force became the major peril on the highseas, for which the assumptions of Plan BLACK made no provision.


Mexican President Victoriano Huerta, Right Chair,
with His Cabinet


Mexico Becomes the Big Problem

But where all of the dangers of war seemed to converge with the most immediate impact was in Mexico. In December 1914, the captain of a Japanese warship visited Mexico City. Japan was aggrieved at the United States and had been preparing for war for over 3 years.

In April 1915, the Japanese battle cruiser Asama was detected maneuvering off the coast of Baja California. The Hearst press, which had so effectively worked Americans into a war fever in 1898, screamed that the Japanese had been using naval bases in Baja California.

In April 1915, the U.S. Government learned of a German plan to put Huerta, who was in exile, back in power.  At this stage of the war, Germany had already begun intrigues to tie the United States down in its hemisphere and prevent it from intervening in Europe. This plot, coming on the heels of the Lusitania crisis, almost brought the United States into the war. It was clear that German attempts to involve the United States in a war with Mexico would continue, and would become the deciding factor regarding U.S. policy. As Secretary of State Lansing put it, “Our possible relations with Germany must be our first consideration, and our intercourse with Mexico must be regulated accordingly.”

A covert operation took Huerta out of the picture, and Germany’s attention turned to Pancho Villa, the next beneficiary of German support. In January 1916, a Germanarmed band of Villistas raided a group of American mining engineers in San Ysabel, in the Mexican state of Chihuahua. Americans called for revenge for the “massacre at San Ysabel.” The next crisis, Villa’s March 1916 raid on Columbus, New Mexico, produced intelligence to suggest that the threat from Mexico was more than bandit gangs.

Among the dead of the Villista raiders was a courier carrying dispatches from Villa to Emiliano Zapata, fighting  in the southern part of Mexico. These dispatches suggested a union of the two revolutionaries “to join in a concentrated attack upon the United States,” and informing Zapata that he had “sent couriers to all states to incite the population against the Americans . . . the common enemies of the Mexicans.”

This was the impetus for the deployment of  Pershing’s punitive expedition in accordance with Plan GREEN, developed by the joint planning board to deal with threats from Mexico and foreign interventions.  By late 1916, the American military was planning for a full-blown war with Mexico. However, President Wilson's more insightful response was to prepare for war with the source of the nation's problems, that is against Germany itself. Accordingly, on 12 January 1917, Wilson told Secretary Baker to withdraw the expedition, in time for the intercept of the Zimmerman telegram in February. In this regard, Wilson was right and the military wrong, for had the United States gone to war with Mexico, it would have played right into German
hands.


Secretary of  War Newton Baker and
General Tasker Bliss


It's 1917

By 1917, the contingencies envisioned by ORANGE [war with Japan] and [the original] BLACK were extremely unlikely—the German fleet was bottled up in the North Sea, and the Japanese fleet was far away from home waters cooperating with Allied navies in the Mediterranean—yet, the United States was not secure.It could not protect its maritime commerce, it had to contend with foreign instigated violence on its southern frontier, and it had to face the prospect of insurrection on its own territory. Further, the situation in Europe was now a factor.

If the Germans won, which in 1917 was a strong possibility, they would feel emboldened enough to expand their influence into the Americas. If the stalemate continued, and the European armies ground each other to powder, then the way would be open for an ever more aggressive Japan. As an estimate prepared by one of President Wilson’s military advisors (LTC Henry T. Allen) concluded, without U.S. involvement none of the principal nations involved in the European war could be destroyed, meaning that the war could not “reconcile the victors to the vanquished” and that postwar Europe could not escape its troublesome nature. 

At this point, American strategy underwent a profound and sudden change. Freedom of the sea lanes, and stability in the American republics could not be achieved by hemispheric defense, but only by the deployment of an expeditionary force large enough to remove the hostile regime. The quick and complete defeat of Imperial Germany, heretofore believed to be of no interest to the United States, was now recognized as essential to American security. Such thinking did not immediately catch on. At one point in April 1917, for example, a U.S. senator buttoned-holed an officer of the General Staff and asked with incredulity, “Good Lord! You’re not going to send soldiers over there, are you?

Army and Navy planners adapted no better than the Senate. While there were aspects of Plan BLACK which were implemented (for example, Navy Secretary Josephus Daniels recounts that the seizure of German and Austrian ships interred in American ports was a provision of BLACK), existing plans were of little value for the dispatch of American forces to Europe.. Under immense pressures of time, the War Department prepared estimates for the new contingency. These envisioned invading Bulgaria through Greece, and of a landing in the rear of the German armies in France through an alliance with the Netherlands.

What Happened in 1917?

None of these concepts was, of course, fit for anything other than the trash, and the time wasted on them actually contributed to the delay of American intervention. No realistic planning was undertaken until the designated commander of the American Expeditionary Force, General Pershing, arrived in Europe to survey the requirement. As Pershing bitterly noted:

When the Acting Chief of Staff (Bliss) went to look in the secret files where the plans to meet the situation that confronted us should have been found, the pigeon hole was empty. In other words, the War Department was face to face with the question of sending an army to Europe, and the General Staff had never considered such a thing.

A later comment of Pershing’s indicates the strain on Army-Navy relations the requirements of the Western Front would cause. Pershing’s estimate that the AEF would number at least 2,000,000 men and would consume over 50,000 tons of freight per day was regarded by Admiral William Sims, the commander of U.S. Naval forces in Europe, as “very much an exaggeration or else as just an army joke.”


The First American Troops Depart for France, 1917


Once planning got underway in Pershing’s headquarters, it assumed the broad outlines of the modern American deliberate planning process, that is, with the theater commander-in-chief outlining requirements, the Army Chief of Staff making provision to provide the forces required, and the Chief of Naval Operations conducting the strategic deployment of those forces. This was the dawn of 20th-century American military history.

Source:  Excerpted from "JOINT U.S. ARMY-NAVY WAR PLANNING ON THE EVE OF THE FIRST WORLD WAR: ITS ORIGINS AND ITS LEGACY" by Colonel Adolf Carlson, 1998.  Full article available HERE.