Now all roads lead to France and heavy is the tread
Of the living; but the dead returning lightly dance.
Edward Thomas, Roads

Wednesday, October 19, 2022

Resistance in Occupied Northern France, 1914-1918


Show of Power: Occupying Lille


From James E. Connolly's The Experience of Occupation in the Nord, 1914-1918

Soon after war was declared and the Germans invaded via the north, local French authorities forbade armed resistance on the part of civilians. The mayor of Roubaix, for example, offered the following advice to the population:

Do not commit any act that could serve as a pretext for terrible reprisals. If an individual commits an act against a German soldier, in the present circumstances it would be criminal folly. Such an act could only be the work of an agent provocateur. This will not occur in Roubaix. We are absolutely counting on the fact that the population of Roubaix will provide a good example of calm and will keep its composure.

Similar advice was proffered in Belgium. This proclamation echoes the reticence of many rural communes to encourage civilian armed resistance during the Franco-Prussian War.  Indeed, what applied to many mayors in 1870 also applied in 1914: their first reflex was to disarm their citizens to ensure that they were not tempted to use such weapons, and to show goodwill towards the invader. Across the Nord, especially in Lille-Roubaix-Tourcoing, the population was asked to deposit all weapons at designated municipal buildings. 


Intimidation: Taking Over the Town Square


Once the Germans arrived, they demanded that locals deposit remaining weapons at the Kommandantur. For local notables such Rouesel, this policy was acceptable because ‘civilians should not take any part in hostilities, weapons could be a danger for the security of troops and in taking them away, the German authority avoided a possible conflict that could cause a dangerous incident for the population.’ Naturally, not everyone complied, such as the Mayor of Noyelles-lez-Seclin, who still possessed a revolver on the final date for handing in weapons. The Germans therefore searched for and requisitioned weaponry throughout the occupation.  Handing in weapons was for many a logical, if difficult, decision.

A civilian caught possessing a weapon risked the death penalty, although imprisonment and forced labour were the most frequent sentences. Whether requisitioned by force or voluntarily handed in, weapons were therefore hard to come by and dangerous to own in occupied France. Further, the concentration of Germans made armed resistance seem futile and suicidal. Troop numbers were higher in larger localities, particularly those with vital railway links or near the front, such as Lille, Roubaix-Tourcoing, Cambrai or Valenciennes. One indicator of the scale of the German presence is that from June to August 1915 a total of 169,191 Germans used Tourcoing’s tramway; from September to November 1915, the total was 194,328, although most were not part of the army of occupation.  Still, the close proximity of tens of thousands of armed Germans, the difficulty in acquiring weapons and severe restrictions on liberty of movement and communication undermined the feasibility of armed resistance. Further, the population was in no physical state to fight. For example, in June 1917, forced labourer Jules Claeys weighed just 38 kilograms after three months’ labour.  Many other sources attest to the poor physiological and psychological state of locals 

Nevertheless, there were isolated incidents of civilian violence, such as the alleged shooting of German sentries (one of whom died) by two civilians in Roubaix in October 1917. One of the ‘murderers’ was shot and killed while trying to flee the German police during a follow-up inquiry. A handful of other examples of individual violence exist, not all clearly acts of resistance, such as Arthur Debiève from Gommegnies who was sentenced to ten years’ captivity for having mortally wounded a German soldier who was stealing his vegetables. However, these remain the exceptions that prove the rule.


The Nuisance of Occupation 


The occupied population did not engage in Werner Rings’ ‘Resistance Enchained’: ‘the desperate fight of those who were cut off, without help, and with practically no hope of surviving.’ Occupied civilians were cut off, but there was hope for survival; they were receiving help, directly from the neutral aid organisations, and indirectly from the Allies’ armed struggle against the Central Powers. As Horne and Kramer note, widespread civilian resistance usually occurs with the defeat of conventional forces,  when all hope of military victory is lost; but occupied Nordistes had faith in the Allied victory. It was not the role of occupied civilians to fight the national enemy.

The nature of the war of attrition, in which huge armies made small gains at great loss, and the flat plains of the Nord (lacking mountainous or wooded terrain useful for guerrilla warfare) also detracted from the feasibility of armed resistance. Despite being convinced by material conditions and patriotism that they lived at the military front, the occupés remained above all civilians, not combatants.

As well as being difficult, armed resistance was discouraged by French municipalities who wanted to avoid bloodthirsty and costly urban warfare involving civilians, which could even lead to social disorder (the Paris Commune was still in living memory). Also, authorities did not wish to give the Germans any pretext for reprisals, as happened in the Franco-Prussian War after franc-tireur attacks on the Prussians. 


Intrusiveness: A German Officer Instructing French School Children, in Champagne


Despite this, but precisely because of commonplace franc-tireur attacks in 1870–71, the Germans saw francs-tireurs everywhere during the invasion and responded in kind. Emmanuel Debruyne argues that atrocities played a major role in discouraging armed resistance in 1914–18. Isabel Hull has also emphasised the foundational role of 1870–71 for the German military,  and argued for a ‘spiral of extremity’ in the occupations of 1914–18 involving ‘untrammelled military power.’  This persuaded local notables and the wider population of the foolishness of resistance.

French authorities also wished to avoid breaching the 1907 Hague Convention, which forbade armed resistance unless partisans were organised into clearly identifiable groups. Such units would be crushed by the Germans, and also ran contrary to the French Government’s abandonment of the invaded regions, whereby even fortress cities such as Lille were declared ‘open cities.’ Guerrilla resistance breaching the Hague Convention would give the Germans a legitimate pretext for reprisals, ‘to prove the enemy right.’ It would also show a lack of respect for the law, and, if anything distinguishes this occupation and particularly the resistance that took place, it is a devotion to, almost adulation of, the law, and the importance of respectability. This is a key part of [understanding] the . . . ‘respectable resistance’,  . . . symbolic expressions of patriotism and opposition, . . . and more active forms of resistance [that actually occurred during the occupation.]

Source: The Experience of Occupation in the Nord, 1914-1918, James E. Connolly, Manchester University Press, 2018


 

Tuesday, October 18, 2022

Palestine: The Ottoman Campaigns of 1914-1918


By Edward J. Erickson
Pen & Sword Military, 2022
Peter L. Belmonte, Reviewer


Ottoman Cavalry

Books in the English language presenting the Ottoman Empire’s side of World War I, whether covering campaigns, strategy, or units, are few and far between. Thankfully, Edward J. Erickson has made an impact in that gap. Erickson, a retired U.S. Army officer and retired professor of history at the U.S. Marine Corps University, has several books focusing on the Ottoman contribution to World War I to his credit. Palestine: The Ottoman Campaigns of 1914-1918 is intended to be a companion volume to Gallipoli: The Ottoman Campaign (Pen & Sword, 2010). Erickson relies heavily on official records (both British and Turkish), as well as a fine array of other primary and secondary sources, to tell this story. His familiarity with, and deep use of Turkish sources makes this a valuable addition to the history of World War I.

In his introduction, Erickson does a wonderful job of describing the distinctions of the Palestinian theater. There were no continuous lines of trenches; actions were characterized by maneuver; battles were of a comparative shorter duration; and campaign rhythm tended to follow the availability (or lack thereof) of supplies. Erickson also argues that, with the absence of mass armies, the part of the individual tended to hold more sway. 


Ottoman Infantry

Along those lines, Erickson states: “It was at the tactical level in Palestine where it may be argued that Ottoman and German commanders provided brilliant leadership” (p. 6). This is largely supported by subsequent chapters, but the author credits Turkish field army commander Mustafa Kemal with “the finest demonstration of battlefield leadership and tactical skill” (p. 7).

Next Erickson covers the campaigns chronologically and geographically within the Palestinian theater. He thoroughly discusses the organization of Ottoman forces, coupled with changes in command, movement into and out of the theater of various units, and logistical challenges. Each chapter is a nice blend of operational and tactical history, together with a good explanation of strategic background. Erickson describes the ebb and flow of combat and movement in the theater.


Ottoman Artillery

By 1917, British General Sir Edmund Allenby proved to be “a master of the operational environment” (p. 124). This, coupled with Ottoman supply difficulties, sealed the Turkish Palestinian army’s fate. Despite the battlefield losses, “it must be remembered that the Ottoman Army was still in the field and actively preparing its defense of the Anatolian heartland when the armistice was signed” (p. 179). In his final chapter, Erickson discusses Ottoman logistics, really an overview of the topic from the previous chapters, and shows the challenges they had to face.

Two appendices give detailed orders of battle for the Ottoman Army in Palestine. The eleven maps in the book are adequate, but, coming from official Turkish sources and written in Turkish, are a bit cumbersome to use. The author and editors would have been better served to use one or two Turkish maps but render the rest in clearer English. Thirty photographs enhance the text and give us a view of the men, terrain, and equipment involved in the campaigns. This book is an important addition to the historiography of World War I. It is highly recommended to anyone interested in the Middle East theater of operations, especially to those who want to read about the Ottoman perspective.

Peter L. Belmonte

Monday, October 17, 2022

Alistair Horne's Letter from Verdun



Rodin Sculpture, Verdun Today


Originally published in Prospect, 20 August 1999

[Editor's Note: Alistair Horne is the author of The Price of Glory, an essential read for anyone interested in Verdun, the Great War, or the Human Comedy / Tragedy.]

From Alistair Horne –

The first thing a visitor sees on entering this small city astride the Meuse is a sculpted figure with its mouth wide open in a terrible silent scream.

It was on 21st February 1916 that Kaiser Wilhelm launched his “limited offensive” against the French bastion of Verdun. With a strategy unprecedented in the history of warfare, he sought to lure the French army into a place it would have to defend for strategic and moral reasons. His choice fell upon the fortress town of Verdun, 150 miles east of Paris. There the French army would be “bled white,” by the Germans’ greatly superior artillery.

War, however-as Nato discovered in Kosovo-seldom turns out the way the generals expect. In the event, Verdun turned out to be an unparalleled disaster for both Germans and French. Not without reason, it has gone down as the “worst battle” in history-perhaps even worse than Stalingrad. It was certainly the longest; its sinister fame derives also from the sheer concentration of the battlefield where, over a period of ten months from February 1916, an area smaller than Manhattan was subjected to the most intensive artillery bombardment ever known.

Along a front only eight miles wide, in the initial six day bombardment, 1,200 German guns expended 2.5m shells (at Waterloo, a century earlier, Napoleon fired off only 20,000 rounds). In the course of the battle, the big guns of both sides exacted over 800,000 French and German casualties. Three-quarters of the whole French army passed, up the lifeline known ever after as the Voie Sacree, through the inferno of Verdun. Few infantrymen ever saw the enemy which was slaughtering them.

For all its horrors, Verdun was a chivalrous battle. Surrendering prisoners were not shot (as they were in Saving Private Ryan). The infantry on both sides felt compassion for each other; the invisible guns were the enemy.


Verdun, 1916


The shelling so tortured the soil around Verdun that whole sections of the countryside defied all attempts to return them to cultivation; the lunar shell-fields still remain, crater upon crater-now partially veiled by dense new woods.

Whereas the fighting elsewhere on the western front took place in trenches now all but effaced by the passage of time, at Verdun it swirled around a series of massive concrete forts which gave the locality its 1914 reputation as the world’s most powerful fortress. Two of these forts, Vaux and Douaumont, saw some of the most lethal fighting. Others, battered and crumbling, now lie concealed in the woods, confronting the occasional venturesome tourist like Shelley’s Ozymandias; half-forgotten monuments to the folly, pride and heroism which epitomised what we still call “The Great War.”

I have been to Verdun half-dozen or more times since writing a book about it, The Price of Glory. I have never failed to be haunted by the majesty of the place-and its sadness. I remember standing at the sombre 50th anniversary commemorations in 1966, within a few feet of General de Gaulle. Erect as a ramrod, he stood until the lengthy son et lumi?re presentation reached the date when he, de Gaulle, had fallen wounded in the battle and been captured. Then he turned and left.

Perhaps it was too much to bear, even for that icy titan. Two decades later it was also to Verdun that François Mitterrand came, solemnly, to seal the end of Franco-German enmity by shaking hands with Helmut Kohl on the battlefield where so many had died.

Verdun is zealous in preserving its ghosts. Yet now, revisiting it for the first time in 12 years, I felt slightly less haunted. The solemnity remains, but time seems to have taken some of the edge off the grimness. In past years there was a creepy absence of birds; now thrushes and larks have returned.

Up on the front line, little-visited by the tourists, is the poste de commandement of Colonel Driant, one of Verdun’s heroes, who died at the head of his 1,300 chasseurs in the first days of the onslaught. Now it is covered with wild strawberries. In the tranquillity it is hard to imagine the terror of the bombardment-without a CNN to record it.

In the pockmarked woods, however, dangers still lurk. Only recently, two French helicopter personnel on leave from Yugoslavia were killed attempting to remove fuses on an unexploded shell.

At Fort Douaumont, swallows nest in the deserted machine-gun cupolas. Now most of its underground chambers, with dripping stalactites-which once housed over a thousand troops-are open to the public. Trees have been allowed to grow on the superstructure, concealing apertures through which a handful of Germans crept to take the world’s most powerful fortress. (Its reconquest cost the lives of 100,000 French troops).

At neighbouring Fort Vaux, where in June 1916 attackers and defenders fought bitterly for a week in the subterranean corridors, with gas and flame-throwers, a touching little plaque from a bereaved French mother has disappeared-vandalised. It read: “? mon fils: since your eyes were closed, mine have never ceased to weep.”


German Troops atop Fort Vaux, 1916

Young Germans-“Jugendaktion 1989”-have been at work clearing and restoring the superstructure of Vaux. A transcending sense of Franco-German reconciliation permeates Verdun today. The excellent museum at Fleury (one of nine villages obliterated in the battle) is entirely non-partisan, all trace of chauvinist heroics removed. Of its 130,000 annual visitors (including many Americans), about 20 per cent are Germans, whom the director takes personal pleasure in guiding around.

But of all the thousands of epitaphs on the Battle of Verdun, the one that sticks most poignantly in my mind is that written over 40 years ago (in The Taxis of the Marne) by a Frenchman, Jean Dutourd, deploring the moral debility of his countrymen in 1940: “War is less costly than servitude,” he wrote, “The choice is always between Verdun and Dachau.”

Alistair Horne

Sunday, October 16, 2022

Voices from the Great War: America on the Battlefields


Americans Ready to Fight, France, 1917

Once at the front, the American troops began to get ready for combat. U.S. Marine Melvin Krulewitch described the physical training he underwent.

All of us went through the tough Marine Corps Training. Which comprised not only the training as Marines, the technical military training, but physical training. When we were in camp we were required to serve one day of training and one day of the hardest physical labour that you can imagine. We handled five-tonne iron and steel beams by hand; we unloaded brick barges by hand; we made the oyster-shell roads by hand. We went on our hikes into the manoeuvre grounds carrying 95 pounds on our back. We got used to that: it was a great pleasure to go back to training after the day of hard work. And, every morning at 4.45, at reveille, we would have 15 minutes of hard physical exercise with the rifle itself – using it as a wand: a nine and a half pound gun.

The newly arrived American soldiers also received basic weapons training. American machine gunner Leon Diament described the equipment that he trained with.

When we arrived in France we had no machine guns. We went in training the best way we could with our small arms, waiting for our machine guns to arrive. Well, they didn’t arrive for about a week, or maybe even a little longer. If I remember, it was about eight or nine days. A shipment of machine-guns finally arrived, and when we opened them, we almost had a revolution. We found we’d received Hotchkiss guns – Hotchkiss machine guns – that was the guns the French Army used. Well, there was a big commotion. The officers got in touch with headquarters and headquarters with supreme headquarters, and back and forth, back and forth, but nothing happened. Next morning the officer came in and said, ‘Men, I’m sorry, that’s it. Those are your weapons, and that’s what you have to use up front. You’d better learn how to operate them. Tout de suite!’ There was a commotion, there was a little resentment but we were good soldiers; we had to take it.

British officer Bill Haine was part of a demonstration platoon that delivered combat training to American troops in 1918.

When we were dragged out of the line to form GHQ troops we still went on training and one of the things which happened was that they formed a number of demonstration platoons. All these people had been a lot of actual warfare and all our fellows had seen a lot of actual warfare and they formed these demonstration platoons to try and instruct other people how to carry on. Well, it was a highly trained platoon and it was there to demonstrate to troops who had not had the experience of war. The discipline was a great thing; I mean we trained like guardsmen as far as the drill was concerned. But then on the battle side, you showed them how you should do things and how you should use your weapons.

Charles Templar of the Gloucestershire Regiment was a signals instructor to the New York Division in 1918.

When I got back to the battalion and was greeted as I was. I was obviously being kept back because I was sent on a separate duty to join the New York Division – the American New York Division – which had just landed in France, only just landed. And they sent me because they wanted me to give instruction and information to the American signallers of the division concerning the sort of work they’d have to do in the front line and the areas around the front line. So I had the signallers in a group and I didn’t try to teach them anything I might talk to them about the sort of things that they could expect.

After this training, behind the lines, U.S. troops joined French and British units in relatively quiet sectors to gain front-line experience. British private Fred Lewis recalled the American soldiers that he served with.

When the Americans came, when they came out, there was about eight and they come to our lot. And the sergeant there, the first words he said when he was in our trenches were, ‘Where are the goddam Germans?’ Someone told him, ‘Just over there.’ I says, ‘You’ll know where they are when you’ve been here a few days, when they start throwing the shells about…!’

Alexander Stanier, an officer in the Welsh Guards, found there were some difficulties caused by the influx of new troops not used to trench life.

They were in very good form they didn’t seem to realise that the Germans were close; they made the most appalling noise which of course frightened the Germans who thought they were going to be attacked, I think. They also had a bet on as to who’d shoot the first German in this battalion. The Germans sent over a patrol to find out what was happening and of course they all let fly and they did shoot the equivalent of a German company sergeant major, who was brought in, dead. And of course then there was the most appalling argument as to who’d shot him, because about a million rounds had been fired. But they were very keen and, as I say, there were too many of them in a small space. They caused the most frightful commotion and the Germans kept on thinking they were being attacked. I had a very uncomfortable time because we had much more shelling while they were there. We kept it all quiet.

Many of the Americans were shocked when confronted with the realities of trench warfare. Leonard Stagg served with the Royal Army Medical Corps.

The Americans when they came over it absolutely jolted them. I remember one of their MO’s saying to me, ‘Do you mean to tell me you chaps have stuck this for three years and more?’ Yes I said. He said, ‘Our chaps will never stick it.’ I remember one of those coming into the room, one was crying – his brother in law had been killed, down near Metz. They’d never experienced war like it; it just really shook them to their very marrows.

The American soldiers were unused to the dangers of front-line service, as British private William Gillman found out.

We liked the Americans. We used to take the mickey out of their boasting; you know, they’d only got to arrive and the war would be won. But of course it wasn’t, and it took some time. Because we knew very well that when they said that they were going to knock out these goddam Jerries and all the kind of thing like that then they got the reverse lesson. They learned, even after repeated warnings from us. Cos they never used to take much notice of us warning them, you know. They were so cocksure that they didn’t know what keeping your head down meant. And they paid a penalty to it, too. They thought they were going to knock old Jerry out just by looking over the top, see. But of course Jerry wasn’t like that and he taught them a lesson. And then as soon as they got used to it and began to realise that even their tin helmets wouldn’t stop bullets! They got more wise to things.

Sometimes, this inexperience had serious consequences—as Horace Calvert of the Grenadier Guards discovered.

We took them into the trenches with us and there were two or three with me and the section I was in. There was a sergeant who was further down and some more. They’d been told not to go out from our trenches unless they told the company on the right and the company on the left, in other words the flank men. And they’d pass it on if there was anybody, not to shoot at any patrol or anybody coming in, crawling in or walking in during the darkness but to challenge and make sure they did that before they did any shooting. Well this American sergeant took two or three men out looking for souvenirs – we told him there weren’t any, there were nothing worth having but he would go out to see if he could get any. And unluckily they got in front of the machine guns of the Irish Guards and they shot them. The sergeant I think did lose his leg and the others were wounded. That, you see, was them not listening.

After they had received their training, the American troops were eager to get into action. Earl Davison served with the U.S. artillery.

There was a general opinion among the men that – let’s get on with it, that if there’s nothing more that you can teach us here, so many miles back from where there’s something doing, we don’t want to stay here forever, we want to get this thing over with, that was general among the men. And we practically broke open a bottle of champagne when the words came that we were to move the next 48 hours, somewhere, we didn’t care where. We’d had enough of this business of play-acting. We wanted to get somewhere where we could do some damage, and get done, get back home.

The first American offensive of the First World War took place in France at Cantigny on 28 May 1918. John Figarovsky witnessed the battle.

And on the day of the battle, they had the tremendous barrage. They had a creeping barrage. I was watching through binoculars and they had a creeping barrage that was slowly creeping towards the town of Cantigny which was situated on high ground. And I could see some of the waves of American soldiers as they went forward. I saw many of them fall. I saw some of them get up and follow the barrage again. And every here and there, there was a Whippet tank with the troops, they did a lot of work when they got to the town those tanks, wiping out some of the machine-gun nests there. And there was so much smoke and so much noise going on from all the barrage and counter barrage, you know, that I couldn’t see very well exactly what was going on.

At the end of May, American troops arrived at Chateau Thierry, south of Soissons, to support the French against German attack. Gunner William Maher remembered what happened.

When we arrived in the Chateau Thierry section our battalion, our guns, went immediately into action in support of the Marines and the infantry who were in the Belleau Woods and Belleau and Bouresches; and we were firing continuously day and night, high explosive, gas, shrapnel. And we realised the importance of saving Paris and the Allied army itself was at stake. And there was a lot heavy work going on there hauling ammunition day and night. We had to keep off the roads in the daytime because we were under the constant observation of the enemy; and during the day we had to hide in the woods and clean our horses and all our equipment and get ready for the next night’s work. Our division suffered very heavy casualties, about 9,800 officers and men; but we felt we had turned the tide and we did a good job.

On 6 June, US Marines went into action against German forces at Belleau Wood. Melvin Krulewitch described the fierce fighting that took place there.

We got into the edge of the woods and we dug in. And we took position there, ready for either an advance again on orders from the top command or for a defence against a counter attack. Now this was the kind of fighting that many Americans knew of; no longer trench system, no trench warfare, but open warfare. The way their ancestors had fought on the frontiers and in all the wars of our country. And we knew it. But the difficulty with Belleau Wood was you never knew where the front was. Little groups of Americans, little groups of Germans got together to fight each other. And while you were fighting in one direction all of a sudden, without any warning, you’d find there were some Germans to the rear of you and they had to be mopped up. Clean up, mop up, and move ahead; move ahead with the unyielding determination to enforce your will on the enemy; and that was how we moved in Belleau Wood.

These American actions contributed to the Allied successes in the summer of 1918. British officer Murray Rymer-Jones was one of many who appreciated the USA’s support in the war.

Those were happy days and things had begun to look up. And so things were getting better and the Americans were down the south. We’d had one of their battalions in Arras in the trench and they were rather delighted that they had an officer killed on their first night. So they felt they were doing their job. I liked them very much, because they were full of enthusiasm, full of guts. They were after all, they’d come over to win the war and they were very good.

Donald Price of the Royal Fusiliers also had a positive opinion of the Americans he encountered.

We were taken down from Ypres right the way down to near Peronne. First time I met the Americans. It was down there somewhere, round Peronne or somewhere, where the Americans had just come in. I loved them; they were all so generous. We didn’t see many of them but we passed a lot once, they were on the side of the road there, chin-wagging and you know, they were pleased to see us, you know, mates. And they were very kind, they gave us cigarettes and chocolates and things like that.

But not everyone was so enthusiastic about them. One of the chief sources of tension was that the Americans earned more money than the British, as Herbert Verrity of the West Yorkshire Regiment explained.

The Americans were very unpopular because they had the money; they didn’t half get big money. So, if you was in small villages and all that there, the shopkeepers didn’t want to know you. Cos their prices was made to suit the Americans with their big money, what they could throw away. So of course that created a lot of bitterness really between the English soldier and the American soldier.

In some cases, animosity between the different nationalities serving alongside each other spilled over into physical violence. Royal Engineer Wilfred Whitlam recalled one such instance.

We was guarding a bridge just behind the lines and a mate of mine and myself went into a café – there was nobody else in the village, like, at all. And we were sat in this café and two Americans came in and of course they were bragging about how they’d come to win the war and all sorts. My mate says, ‘Shall I go and give him one?’ He’d been a boxer. I said, ‘Aye. I’ll look after the other one if he interferes.’ He just gave him one punch and he went flying over the top of the tables! The other chap was going to his help but I got hold of the scruff of his neck and said, ‘You mustn’t interfere or else you’ll get the same.’ And with that they went!

Despite these tensions, the overall contribution of America to the First World War was a key factor in the Allies’ ability to turn the tide against Germany in 1918. German officer Hartwig Pohlmann remembered how the numbers of men on the Western Front gradually tipped the scale in the Allies’ favour.

In July 1918 we tried to cross the River Marne but after three days we had to fall back. The resistance of the enemy was too heavy and there we met first American troops and now we knew from month to month more and more American troops will come to the front line and the enemy will become overwhelming for us. But we knew that we had to do our duty as soldiers and it was a matter of the politicians to find a way to a fair peace and so we did our duty as long as we could and most of the German soldiers did so. We had very heavy losses in that year and the units became smaller and smaller, we had to combine to form one company out of two and so on. The number of our guns diminished.

Many years after his service with the U.S. Army on the Western Front, Harvey Maness reflected on his experiences as one of over two million Americans who took part in the war.

All wars are hell. All wars are useless. All wars are futile. Nevertheless when I went in, I was just… this was the only war that was ever going to be fought to end all wars and to make the world safe for democracy. I believed that – the only war that’s ever been fought to make the world safe for democracy and to end all wars. Just think if we had ended that. To tell you the truth, I’m very fortunate to come through World War One and be in shape I am. I’m so happy and proud to be in this stage in life; came through all of that and still in good health. I’m so grateful and thankful.

Saturday, October 15, 2022

Voices of the Great War: America Enters the War


Preparedness Day Parade, New York City, 13 May 1916

From the Imperial War Museum, London


When war broke out in Europe in 1914, the United States of America adopted a policy of strict neutrality. There was little support amongst the American population for entering the war, despite early reports of German atrocities. Benjamin Muse was living in America in 1914.

There was a lot of propaganda and that was disturbing, exaggerated propaganda over that period, which was really outrageous when you look back on it. One got the impression from reading the papers and hearing the talk that the Germans, or the Huns as we called them then, were a hoard of barbarians who were descending on Europe, about to plunge Europe into another Dark Ages. We read about how they slaughtered women and children, threw babies up into the air and caught them on their bayonets, tortured prisoners of war and all that. I didn’t believe all that, in fact I wondered if the Germans were barbarians of that type. And, if they were, why we hadn’t heard more about it before this war started.

The U.S. wanted to stay completely out of the conflict, but found this increasingly difficult due to Germany’s policy of unrestricted submarine warfare. In May 1915, when a German U-boat sank the RMS Lusitania, 128 US citizens lost their lives. This was a key turning point in America’s attitude to the war. Walter Greenwood, a schoolboy in Britain at the time, remembered the anger felt towards Germany after the attack.

Well the news suddenly went round that the Lusitania had been sunk and all the women turned out, furious, cursing the Germans. And suddenly they began to talk about the people running shops who had got German-sounding names. Groups began to form and somebody rushed round and said Keppel’s, pork butcher’s shop had been broken into by a crowd of women and all the eatables stolen.

In response to American outrage, Germany abandoned unrestricted U-boat attacks—but resumed them again early in 1917. This, coupled with the news that Germany had proposed an alliance with Mexico to threaten American interests, finally brought America into the war in April 1917. U.S. Army veteran Harvey Maness remembered the American president, Woodrow Wilson’s, reluctance to enter the war.

Well that was the grand climax. You know, they had the U-boats and that was their secret weapon and they came darn near winning. But that really broke the backbone of American sentiment; on April 6th 1917 President Wilson declared war. We stayed out as long as we could, you know he went in; Wilson went in the second term with the theory he was going to keep us out of war – well, three months later we were in war. But he didn’t declare it; it was forced on us: we had to go, to defend our rights. So, see those U-boats were going to put us out of business; keep America getting in the war. And if we hadn’t gotten in at the last minute, Germany would’ve won that war.

America was not ready for war. The country had to mobilize, and prepare its armed forces for battle. The U.S. Army was small in size, but conscription was soon introduced to expand it. The first US troops arrived in France in June 1917. John Figarovsky, of the 1st Infantry Division, was amongst them.

When we landed one of the first things we did is to parade through the town. We paraded through St. Nazaire and the French people were just so delirious with joy, because in the Americans they saw hope for the future, that we might, you know, end the war quicker with the Americans coming there. As we marched through town, the sidewalks and even the gutters on both sides were full of people, and we felt so proud and important that such a fuss was being made over us. We were most of us young, and looking forward to the fight, and we didn’t know how serious war is because we had never been in war before. To us it was just one big adventure ahead of us.

British officer Richard Tobin remembered his reaction as the new U.S. troops arrived at the front.

When we were out of the line we used to stand by the road and watch the fresh, strong, plump and new American battalions swing by. They waved and laughed and shouted. Our boys stood by the side of the road and grinned back. But we wondered: did they know? Could they do it? Would they do it? But we were pleased to see them.

The United States Navy was also mobilised. U.S. warships joined with the British Grand Fleet to help guard convoys. In November 1917, a battleship division sailed to Scapa Flow. British officer Lennox Boswell recalled the positive relationship between American and British naval personnel during the year they worked together.

The American squadron sailed for home on the first of December: just under a year from their arrival at Scapa. The squadron, on arrival, consisted of the New York; Texas; Wyoming; Florida and Delaware. During the year they were with us, the squadron was completely integrated into the Grand Fleet in every way. For instance, American officers were piped over the side just like our own officers, and not in accordance with the customary courtesies for foreign officers. Some very nice signals were made when the Americans went – on both sides – and everybody obviously hoped that it would be repeated some time.

The arrival of the American troops acted as a much-needed morale boost for the war-weary Allied soldiers. By the spring of 1918, they were arriving on the Western Front in large numbers. Clifford Lane of the Hertfordshire Regiment explained the importance of this, given the depleted state of British forces at that time.

Well, we knew that they were coming. I think it must’ve helped quite a bit really because there’s no doubt that we were getting at the end of our tether, you know. There’s no doubt about that. I mean all the people who’d got the experience were getting tired and nerve-racked and that sort of thing. And the youngsters really didn’t know what it was all about, you know the younger people. And we were running out of troops; they were using boys of 18 and a half, you see, or just over that. I think, myself, it’s only an opinion, that if the Americans hadn’t come in, it would either have been stalemate – because the Germans had had enough too – and there would have had to have been a negotiated peace. That’s what I think. But the fact that these Americans – thousands, hundreds of thousands of them – strong, healthy lads, well-equipped, their strength hadn’t been impaired in any way, they were ready to go just as we were in 1914. You can just imagine what the Germans thought of it, anyway. They must’ve known – they knew what was going to happen, you see.

Part II presented tomorrow

Thursday, October 13, 2022

Fighting Airmen of Two World Wars—Part 2 of 4: British Fighter Pilots

[Editor's note:  This series is being presented on each of the Thursdays during October 2022. MH]

By Adrian Roberts

Part 1 of this series looked at some German airmen who saw combat in both World Wars. The remaining parts will deal with some well-known Allied airmen. The RAF was stricter than the Germans about the age limits of combat fliers, so the definition of combat in the following examples will be broader.  Part 2 looks at some who were RAF fighter pilots.



Stanley Vincent was the only Allied pilot who is believed to have shot down aircraft in both wars. He was born in 1897, learned to fly at Brooklands in 1915, and was posted to 60 Squadron RFC. He scored the first victory for this squadron, in July 1916, when he shot down an LVG two-seater while flying the very unstable Morane Type N “Bullet”. He brought down two more enemy aircraft before being posted back to the UK in March 1917 as an instructor. He was then hospitalized for seven months after a crash but helped develop the systematic methods of flying training that have been in use ever since. 

He remained in the RAF between the wars, and during the Battle of Britain, as a group captain (for Americans, this is equivalent to a navy captain or army colonel) he was the station commander of the Fighter Command airfield at Northolt. He insisted on flying a Hurricane on operations, which was outside of his duties. He flew most of his sorties alone, so his actual score of enemy aircraft destroyed is unclear, but his citation for the Distinguished Flying Cross states: “…up to the end of September 1940, he has made some dozen sorties alone….he met 15 Dornier 215’s and turned them back, damaging one.  [On another occasion], he destroyed one of a large enemy formation, and created so much confusion that another Messerschmitt 109 was shot down by its own side….” 

Later in the war, he was lucky to escape from Singapore before its surrender. He retired as an air vice-marshal (a two-star rank) and died in 1976.



James Ira “Taffy” Jones was a proud Welshman, born in 1896. He joined the Royal Flying Corps, first as a ground wireless operator then as an air observer in BE2c aircraft, dropping his Lewis gun overboard on one occasion. He was commissioned and learned to fly in  October 1917 and flew SE5a scouts with 74 “Tiger” Squadron, scoring 37 victories in three months from May 1918, making him the highest-scoring Welsh ace. Unfortunately he is said to have crashed 28 of his own aeroplanes! He idolized his first CO, the ace Edward (Mick) Mannock, and wrote his biography, King of Air Fighters. 

He retired in 1936 but served again in WWII, as a wing commander (lt-col equivalent) commanding various training units. During the Battle of Britain, he was so enraged at the sight of German bombers seemingly unscathed that he jumped into a Hawker Henley, a two-seat version of the Hurricane that was only ever used as a target tug, and intercepted a Junkers 88 but being unarmed could only fire his Verey pistol at it. 

During 1941 he unofficially flew in several operations over France in Spitfires with Tiger Squadron, though he found that air combat had changed a lot since 1918, as he describes it in one of his books as “bloody fast fighting!” He died in 1960 after falling off his roof while fixing his TV aerial.



Sydney Carlin was another 74 Squadron ace flying the SE5a. Born in 1889, he enlisted in the 18th Royal Hussars at the outbreak of war, and was awarded the Distinguished Conduct Medal while still a lance corporal. He was then commissioned, and while leading a Royal Engineers detachment, he lost his lower left leg at Delville Wood in August 1916. It seems that the only way that he could get back into a combat role was to join the RFC and learn to fly. Maybe it was thought that airmen didn’t need to walk; the Australian ace Frank Alberry had also lost a leg before joining the RFC (and had also been awarded the DCM, at Pozières). Carlin, now nicknamed “Timbertoes,” scored ten aerial victories, including five balloons from June to September, but was then shot down and became a POW. He returned to civilian life after the war but like many others found it difficult to settle and spent the inter-war years living in different parts of the empire, mainly Kenya.

He returned to the UK at the outbreak of WWII, and despite his disability and his age of 50, he managed to rejoin the RAF and train as an air gunner. He flew with 151 squadron in Defiant turret night-fighters, based at RAF Wittering. He also unofficially flew a few operations as a tail gunner in Wellington bombers. On 9 May 1941, Wittering was attacked by a lone Junkers 88. Sources differ as to the precise circumstances, but what is certain is that Carlin was heading out to his aircraft rather than taking cover when he was caught in a bomb blast and killed. 

Wednesday, October 12, 2022

After Wilson — Harding and America's Return to Normalcy


Warren G. Harding Campaigning in 1920


The aftermath of the war in America was tumultuous. President Wilson's illness and his ill-fated effort to push through the League of Nations had recently dominated national politics. Economic disruptions followed from demobilization as industries re-tooled and work needed to be found for the 4.7 million able-bodied men who had been called to arms. Labor and racial discontent festered. Much of the nation, especially the returning veterans, was utterly perplexed and seething over the recently implemented Volstead Act enforcing Prohibition. All this was on American's minds during the fall of 1920 when the nation was to elect a new president. The most likely frontrunner, Theodore Roosevelt, had surprisingly died in 1919, brokenhearted over the loss of his son Quentin in the war. President Wilson, still debilitated after his stroke, was absent from the campaign trail.

A fresh face representing a steady approach to governance was needed to restabilize American life. The face was that of Ohioan Warren Gamaliel Harding; his policy came to be known as a "Return to Normalcy." Before his nomination, Warren G. Harding declared, “America’s present need is not heroics, but healing; not nostrums, but normalcy; not revolution, but restoration; not agitation, but adjustment; not surgery, but serenity; not the dramatic, but the dispassionate; not experiment, but equipoise; not submergence in internationality, but sustainment in triumphant nationality.”

Most of America Rejected Prohibition


A war- and world-weary electorate handed the U.S. senator and former newspaperman—whom it was universally agreed, "looked like a President"—a landslide victory over his Democratic challenger and fellow Ohioan, James M. Cox, making Harding the 29th U.S. president (1921–23). Most remembered for the Teapot Dome scandal, which came to light after his death in 1923, Harding's Administration had some notable achievements including the calling of the Washington Arms Conference, cutting down the wartime controls and bureaucracy, limiting immigration to allow for assimilation of the tens of millions arrived since the turn of the century, improving the budget process, and proving sympathetic to minorities and business innovation. Ironically though, Harding's "Return to Normalcy" in many ways helped set the stage for the Roaring Twenties, which turned out to be anything but normal.


Sources: Encyclopedia Britannica, Library of Congress, The White House Website


Tuesday, October 11, 2022

Fighting the Kaiser’s War: The Saxons in Flanders 1914/1918


By Andrew Lucas & Jurgen Schmieschek
Pen & Sword Military, 2022
Ron Drees, Reviewer


The Royal Saxon Army—20th & 19th Century


With the fall of the Berlin Wall and German reunification, archives were opened to researchers, and this book is one result. It is profusely illustrated with photos and maps. The photos are of individuals and group shots of soldiers, along with bunkers, trenches, funeral processions, grave sites, destroyed villages, and drawings of trench layouts.

Saxony is a state in southeastern Germany, south of Berlin and forming Germany’s eastern boundary with Poland and its southern boundary with Czechoslovakia. Leipzig and Dresden are two major cities. In 1914 Saxony had its own king who could not participate in foreign policy, apparently the fiefdom of the Kaiser. However, the men of Saxony went off to war with the rest of Germany. 

Fighting the Kaiser’s War gives the point of view of the individual soldier and his fighting and suffering. The soldiers described here took part in far more raiding of trenches and mining than one might understand from more general texts. One can read of soldiers suffering from lack of food, sleep and the impossibility of maintaining any semblance of personal hygiene. Good friends are lost while mail from home brings a bit of joy—and food and money. Perpetual flooding brought on by autumn rains makes staying dry a priority and an impossibility.

Units did not stay in one place but were transferred from one part of the front to another and sometimes to a totally different front. Units would suffer so many casualties that they were merged into other units and their original identity would be lost.

The text is peppered with German words, many of which are not in the main glossary at the end of the book, making some topics difficult to understand. A very poignant part of the book is the last major chapter where letters of individual soldiers, ranging from enlisted men to a major general, are printed. Some of these men survived the war, including one who died of the flu shortly after returning home. In another case, three sons from one family died.

Perhaps the tragedy of the Great War is summed up in a wedding picture in the last chapter. Neither of the couple are smiling. A soldier, undoubtedly medically discharged, stands with his empty left sleeved tucked into a uniform pocket. His bride, her arm tucked into his right, wears a floor length veil, holds a bouquet but is dressed in a black gown. The caption does not explain if the bride is mourning a lost family member or for Germany as a whole, but it communicates a very bittersweet day.

There are no grand sweeping triumphs in this book, just everyday fighting and dying. It shows the Saxons were much like everyone else; they believed in their cause while profusely wishing for an end to the war. Those who want to understand the Great War at the trench level should read this book, especially if they have an intermediate or more advanced level of understanding of the Great War.

Ron Drees

Monday, October 10, 2022

Three Battles at Beaumont en Verdunois (Village Détruit)


Prewar Beaumont

Beaumont en Verdunois, believed to have been founded in 324 AD,  suffered in war throughout the ages, including the Thirty Years War, Napoleon's last campaigns, and the Franco-Prussian War. The Great War, however, would be irreversibly fatal for the community.  Located nine miles north of Verdun overlooking the River Meuse, it was destined to become one of the nine villages détruit (destroyed) on the Verdun battlefield that have never been reoccupied. Unique among the nine, though, Beaumont  found itself bombarded and trampled by infantry in each of the three years before war's end.


Today with Memorial Chapel

In September 1914 the 186 residents were evacuated from the village, which was left temporarily in no man's land. In October 1914, it was occupied by French troops who turned the site into a strong point.  Beaumont, unluckily, was just behind the front line where the initial German assault took place on 21 February 1916.  Defending Caures Wood to the north, in the most advanced position, were the chasseurs of Lt. Col. Emile Driant. Despite the chasseurs' heroic resistance, the woods fell and Colonel Driant ordered a  retreat to Beaumont. When the columns emerged from the wood, they came under withering German machine gun fire. The colonel, who was bringing up the rear, was killed, but fragments of his  sections managed to reach Beaumont and reinforce the garrison there.



Memorial at Village Cemetery


Twenty-four February was the critical day. From the village, components of two French regiments (four companies) fought off repeated attacks. As the troops of the 18th German Corps entered the village, machine guns firing from cellar windows mowed them down. The enemy formations, which were particularly dense, advanced so quickly, with each wave passing the previous one, that the French automatic fire first seemed to overwhelm them, and they suffered terrible losses. The Germans started systematically shelling the village again. When the infantry attack was renewed they once again met with fierce resistance but the balance of forces was now too uneven. As more of the assaulting troops managed to break through, the French officers realized a withdrawal was necessary.  The French were able to keep an escape route open and some of their survivors were able to escape.the following morning. Beaumont was lost and it would become a formidable strong point throughout the remainder of the 1916 battle for the German Army.

In the summer of 1917,  General Petain ordered a limited offensive to recapture some of the terrain lost the previous year that had not been regained in France's fall counteroffensive of 1916. After considerable shelling, on 26 August, two regiments, the 154th RI and the 155th RI, attacked but failed to retake Beaumont, which remained in German hands. On 2 September, a final French attack failed to retake the Beaumont sector. The village—now merely ruins—would stay in enemy hands until the American Meuse-Argonne Offensive of 1918.


Men of the U.S. 26th Division at Beaumont, November 1918


General Pershing's First Army, which included some French divisions, concentrated its initial assault west of the Meuse River.  However, inconvenient artillery fire from the heights east of the Meuse, where Beaumont is situated, compelled him to attack the German forces there. On 8 October, the French 26th Division finally recaptured the village but then came under withering artillery and gas fire. They got no further than the village. An American division (coincidentally, the U.S. 26th Division) was moved into the area at the start of November and fought an exhausting struggle for the remainder of the war against determined resistance.


Mural at the Memorial Chapel


In 1919,  Beaumont was declared a "red zone", meaning that it was forbidden to rebuild the village and return the land to farming. In 1920, the prefect appointed a municipal commission. In 1925, a monument was built to the memory of the children of Beaumont who died for France. Afterwards, to honor the ancestors' memory and pay another tribute to the native sons who died on the battlefield, the interior of the cemetery was leveled, the walls raised, and a monument erected engraved with the text of the army's citation to the village and the names of its war dead. In 1932, the decision was taken that on the fourth Sunday in September, the patron saint's feast day (Saint Maurice), "the former inhabitants and their families would gather to honor their dead and breathe the air of the land where they were born," a tradition that carries on today. A chapel for conducting the service was built between 1932 and 1933. 

Sources:  French Ministry of Defense; American Armies and Battlefields in Europe